Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

cgal-discuss - Re: [cgal-discuss] Create a coarse surface mesh produces areas of very small elements

Subject: CGAL users discussion list

List archive

Re: [cgal-discuss] Create a coarse surface mesh produces areas of very small elements


Chronological Thread 
  • From: Sebastian Bachmann <>
  • To:
  • Subject: Re: [cgal-discuss] Create a coarse surface mesh produces areas of very small elements
  • Date: Thu, 25 May 2023 09:15:39 +0200
  • Authentication-results: mail2-smtp-roc.national.inria.fr; spf=None ; spf=Pass ; spf=None
  • Ironport-data: A9a23:jT0Y/a0TPkfS7PXvGPbD5ex1kn2cJEfYwER7XKvMYbSIYAKW5UVUm TNDRzPGb6i61lGFeo1yat/k/RgP7MSHy4cwSlFqrHg8RixD8ZKZVYzAchb6ZS/LI5SbF046v slDZNXKdpxvHieM+Uf9auPopHMt3MlkKlac5MvsY0idEic/FXtx0HqP4tIEv7OEoeRVIivXt 9+p8seFNQH1gTIubGkes/6PpUpl46X+tG4V4gc3aNlG7QTU/5U3JMJGdPvpdxMUYaENQ7XkH 76bpF2d1jmEl/v4Ior9yt4XSmVTHviIe1LmZkN+A8CKmgJFqjE5zpE1Pf8dbVY/oziSlrid8 v0U3XCLYVlvZvWkdNg1CUECSHkjZ/EepNcrHFDm2SCt5x2eG5fT6642ZK0GFdVw0vp6B2hI6 csZJFglBvxUr7/eLBqTE4GAt+x7RCXZFNt3VkJIkVk1Oc0braXrGM0m0zP3MAAY3aiiFd6GD yYQhKEGgB7oO3WjMX9PYH4ycXvBatASvFS0pXrMzZfb7VQ/wyR6wefmAdz0deaoWMdkpRiCn z/koU7AV0Ry2Ny3kVJp81qph+PAlDn3HpgfE63+/+ICbF+7nzNNTkxQCgv9+KLh4qK9c4o3x 0g8+icqqa8a7kGsXp/0Q3VUpVbd5k9BBIsITLJSBAel9ono6hiILzI9SBVvdv8/r/QSZ2QE/ wrc9z/uLWcz4OPFECz1Gq2vhTi9MCxQIW4ZbjIfViMe8tz7qccyiAjOR5BtCsaIYsbdHDD8z DmQoG4kirIDy8cXv0mmwbzZqzm9+ZP4SC863CfKXFOesBlAOaz7TbX9vDA38s18BIqeS1CAu l0NlM6f8P0CAPmxeMqlEL1l8FaBt6/tDdHMvbJ8N8R4rWX8oBZPaagBvGAnfC+FJ+5eIWeBX aPFhe9GzLN+VEZGgIdyYo6+At4mi7LtEsSjX+y8gjtyjnpZL1bvEMJGPB74M4XRfK4Ey/5X1 XCzKJbEMJriIf47pAdavs9EuVPR+ggwxHnIWbfwxAm93LyVaRa9EOlVbArTNbhivfjZ+m05F uqz0ePak32zt8WuO0HqHXI7cAtiwYUTX8qm9ZwMLIZv3CI2QDtwV5c9Po/Ni6Q+w/QLxr6Wl p1Mck9V1Ej5iGePLgOOa3ZuAI4Drr4vxU/XyRcEYwz0s0XPl67ytP9HH3b2FJF8nNFeIQlcE 6ZZIJTcXa0RItkFkhxEBaTAQEVZXEzDrWqz0+CNPlDTprYwGVabycyuZQb16igFAwy+sMZ08 fXq1RrWTdBHD05uBdrfIqDnhV6gn2kvqMQrVWvxI/5XZBrN9qpuIHfPlfMZGZwHBijC4Tq47 DyoJykki9PDmKIPy+mRt5u499+oN8BcAntlG3Lq6OfqFCvCoUum74xycMeJWjH/RVHLqfmGY MsN7vDjMc8omERBnJp8Ho1Kk4M/xYrLjJ1Lwjt0GE7kawyQNYphBX2dzO9ztqFp7Z1IizucA 06g1IFTBuSUBZnDDlUUGjsAUs2C8vMlwh/p8vU/JRTB1h9dpbaofx1bAEiRtXZ7MrBwDYICx NUhsu4w7yiUqEIjEvSCvxBu21W8FF4yeIR5ichCG67usBQh9X9aa5+FCiPW3oCGW+8RDmYUe A2rlIjwrJUC4HqaaHciN2n/7cwEj7Q0hR165lsjJVOIp9n7usEKzCBhqTQZcikFzzFs8f5CB WxwBkgkeYSM52hJgeZAbUCNGiZAJgGQxXb3+msrl0nfbU2iDWPQHV0EOMKm3kMQw0RDdBd1o ZCaz2fEV27xXcfThyEdZ29sm8bBf/dQqDLQvd+BNNuUOaU6bR7OoL6cVUBRpzTJWcoO1VD6/ 8909+NOWIjHHC83oZxjLbKF1L4VGSu2FEYbTd5PpKo2THzhIhes0j2zKme0SMNHB9rO1WSaU 8VOBMZ+Zy6S5Ra0jAIwJPAzeudvvfsT+tA9VKvhJjcGv5uhvzNZis/s2RaktlA7YedFsJgbG tvKeiOgA16goyJeu1XwofluPku6Ztg5ZzPA4t2lzdVRKbU9tLBDTEJj9Jq1oHSfDyV/9T22o g7oRvHb3s5i+6tWjqruFaRIAjuqJPiuVOij0RuStu5WZojlKvb+tAIyq3jmMT9JPLAXZc9Fq LSVvPPz32LHpLwTUV2Fq6KeFqJM29q+bNBXPu3zMnNeuymIA+3o3Dcu5EG6LsZvvO5Gx8z6W Ta9VtS8ReQVV/hZ2ndRTSpUSDQZKqbva5bftTGPlOuNBjcdwD74Aouer1GxVl5idwgMJ5HaI S33saz35tln8aJ9NCVdDPRiW5JFMFvvXJU9TOLItB6aMDiYsgvX8P+q3x8t8irCBXS4Ad73q 8CNDAT3cBOp/rrE1pdFuoh1pQcaF2t5nfJ2RE8G5tpqkHqvOQbq9wjG3UkuUfm4UxAe1a0Uo BnIbWctAD/xGy5JdgW66ciLssJzwAAREo+RG9Dr1xr8h+SK6EeoGrZm5mFp/x+avxP9mfq/J 4h2FmLYZ3CML1IAeQrXzua2hvchz++yKrfkP6ziu5SaPivyyonmGJCs8MShmMAH/wzweJ33G FUI
  • Ironport-hdrordr: A9a23:/M/y/qg7rAFvbGIaJPxAUKPrlnBQXssji2hC6mlwRA09TyXqrb HNoB1773XJYVkqNE3I9ervBEDEewK4yXcX2+Ys1NWZMTUO0VHAROpfBMnZsl7d8kbFl9K1u5 0BT5RD
  • Ironport-phdr: A9a23:hniM8hPSVkM3LR1SXaQl6nZmBhdPi9zP1u491JMrhvp0f7i5+Ny6Z QqDv6gr1wCXFtyCt7ptsKn/jePJYSQ4+5GPsXQPItRndiQuroEopTEmG9OPEkbhLfTnPGQQF cVGU0J5rTngaRAGUMnxaEfPrXKs8DUcBgvwNRZvJuTyB4Xek9m72/q99pHNYwhEnjSwbLFzI Rm5sAndq8YbipZ+J6gszRfEvnRHd+NKyG1yOFmdhQz85sC+/J5i9yRfpfcs/NNeXKv5Yqo1U 6VWACwpPG4p6sLrswLDTRaU6XsHTmoWiBtIDBPb4xz8Q5z8rzH1tut52CmdIM32UbU5Uims4 qt3VBPljjoMOjgk+2/Vl8NwlrpWrw6iqRJxzIHaYJybOuRwfqzfZt4aQHZNU9xLWiBdHo+xb Y0CBPcBM+ZCqIn9okMDowagCga3Huzv0SNIhn7s0q08zu8sDBvJ0xAgH9ILqnvUqtP1P7oVX OC10qbIyTHDb/RN1Dfn9ofIdR8greuWUrJsaMfcz1QkGAzZgFuKs4PlIy+V2foXs2id9+dtW v+ihnM7pg1vrTWiyMMhhpXKi4waxF7K+zt0zYc2KNGlVEN3f9CpHIdfuiyYM4Z6X8wvTn9pt SsmyrALpJC2cS4Xw5opwB7fbuaIc4mO4h/7W+aRICt4hHJ4eL2knRq97U+gyuj6W8Kp01hKt jJInsTOu30MzRDe7tKLR/l+80u7xDqC2Rzf5+dZKk4uj6XbMYQuwrsom5oTr0vDGij2lV3zj K+Xa0ok9fKn6/76bbn8vJ+TKYh0iw7kPqs0hsyzGeU4Mg4QUGiH4emwyb/u8EzjTLhOlPE7k KrUvIrHKckVuqK1GwpV3Zwi6xa7ATemytMYnXwfIVJFZh2Hi4zpO1bVLfDiE/i/hFutnC1xy PDaJrHhBI7CIWDZkLj9ZbZ991JcyA0rwNxC/55UEK0OIOrvWk/ts9zVFgM2MwOuzObjEdlyy 4IeWXmTDa+EK6PSqkSF5vkvIumJfI8aoizxK/kj5/70jH82g0URfaez3chfVHftFftvJwCVY GHnn8waOWYMpAs3CuLw23OYVjsGXHu4Vrkg5zg9QKivBofGT4aryOiB0SO/GbVMa2dWTFmQR yS7P76YUusBPXrBavRqlSYJAODJo+4J0BivsFW/0L97Nq/O/SZes5v/1d9z7umVlBco9DUyA d7Om3qVQTRSmWUFDyQzwLg5uVZ0n1eO1ax/q+ZVEswV7u8aGhwiO8vkxvdhQ8v3RhqHe96IT Fi8RdDzATw1StUZ2dIJcwB0B4bqlQjNigytBbJdjLmXHNo0/6bbimD2PNp4wm3a2bMJilgqT cJVOSu8i6lvsQHPb2LQu2OekaviNaEV3SqXsXyG0XLLpkZTFgh5TaTCW3kbIErQt9XwoE3YH feoDvw8Pw1NxNTnSOMCY8D1jVhAWPboOcjPK2O3lWCqAB+Ux7SKJIP0cmQZ1S/ZBQAKiQcWt XqBMAE/AG+mrQe8RHRuGFbrZGv2/O5u7nqnDwc1wwyMc0x9xu+t4BdGzfeYSv4VwvcFoHJ49 GsyTRDij5SPUILTwmgpNL9Rat48/lpdgGfQtggne4elM7gnnFkVNQJ+o0Lp0RxzTIRGi8kj6 n0wn28QYeqV1k1MczSA0NX+ILrSfyPy8RSrbIbM11bOlt+KsPRH+LEjplPvsRv8XEov93Fg+ 8NY1Gva74mAX29wGdrhF00w8RZ9vbTTZCIwspjV2XNbOq6xqjbe2tgtCYPJ0z6YdsxEeOOBH Q72SYgBAtS2bfYtkB6vZw4FO+Zb8Og1Odmnfr2IwvzjMOFllTOgxWNJheI1mkKB8y57YvTF2 IZDyu3Q0gacVjj6hUusqYiuxt4CNHdNTizmknCsDZUZfqBoeIcXFWqia9a6wNlznd+IOTYQ9 VKuAU8HxN78fBOTa1Ln2ggDnU8ToHGhhW6512ktzG9v/+zAjGqXmLyxEXhPcnRGT2Rjk1r2d I29jtRAGVOtcxBsjhyuo0Dz26lcoq17aWjVW0ZBOSbsfAQAGuO9sKSPZ8lX5dYmqyJSBa68b FSeTZbnrhwKlSr/VTgW1HUgejemt4+s1Rx3jGaaBGx+q2qfcN06lnK9rJTMAPVW2DQBXixxj zLaU0O9M9ee9tKRj57fs+q6WjHpRthJfCLs14/FqDqj6DggH0ikh/7q0I6Cc0BywWrh2tJtT ymNsBvsftyhyfGhKew+NgphTBz5+4I/E4V62OPcnbk23n4XztWQ9HsDyyLoNMlDnLj5ZzwLT CIKxNjc5E7k3ldiJzSH3dCxUHLV2cZna9SgBwFekisg88BHDruV571YjGN0pFS/twfYffl6m H8U1/Iv7HcQh+xBthAqy22RBbUbHE8QOiKJ9VzA99elsKBef3qia5C11UZxlMqtSquPpREaU Wq4MpYuECls79luZVLB1Hqgj+OsMNLUbN8VqliVi0KZ0LYTedRuxrxT3nI0XAC19WcowOM6k xF0iJSzvYzdbn5o4Lr8GBlTcDv8e8IU/Djpy6dYhMefmY61TfADUn0GWoXlSfWwHXccr/PiY kyOHTk4rV+BFL3PWwaDohQDzTqHA9WwOnebKWNMh81lXwWYLVdDjRo8WTQ2kZcjGkawycvxN k5lrGN0hBawul5HzeRmMAP6W2HUqVKzazs6f5OYKQJf8gBI40q92Sm29O90D2dR4s/5xORsA mmaawtBF21PQEGDFxbqIuv2jTEv2/KVAfr4JuecON2z
  • Ironport-sdr: 646f0b1c_xLBKLINSuVElkkGcHMhev+3u4D1A10fE2K3x1N6MfJEYP9a BLVeKgnHCWn5DRZq4XY8dgw3RTXWSiTsXfKEpDg==

I tested this now in 5.5.2 (according to github it should be in there as well?) but I cannot see any difference to 5.4 - except when using the custom init (see attached image). Code is still this one: https://gist.github.com/reox/0df1f446f0ff9d46e0688b60e8e858b8

Best,
Sebastian

On 25.05.2023 08:32, Sebastian Bachmann ( via cgal-discuss Mailing List) wrote:
Hi!
Thanks for the hint as well!
I'm usingĀ  5.4 / 1050401000.
I'll also test with 5.4.4 (looks like that is the version where it was merged?)

However, also the custom initialization works really good so far.
I fixed the seed for the random number generator to get deterministic results, which works very well.

Best,
Sebastian


On 25.05.2023 08:15, Jane Tournois wrote:
Hello,

this local over-refinement issue has been fixed in the master branch by the following pull-request :
https://github.com/CGAL/cgal/pull/6978

Which version of CGAL are you using?

Best,

Jane.

Attachment: cgal.jpeg
Description: JPEG image




Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.

Top of Page