Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

cgal-discuss - Re: [cgal-discuss] Sliver Treatment in 3D Delaunay Triangulation

Subject: CGAL users discussion list

List archive

Re: [cgal-discuss] Sliver Treatment in 3D Delaunay Triangulation


Chronological Thread 
  • From: Sebastien Loriot <>
  • To:
  • Subject: Re: [cgal-discuss] Sliver Treatment in 3D Delaunay Triangulation
  • Date: Wed, 20 Mar 2024 09:03:37 +0100
  • Authentication-results: mail3-smtp-sop.national.inria.fr; spf=None ; spf=Pass ; spf=None
  • Ironport-data: A9a23:+LTOXaP+4wRg5/XvrR0Hk8FynXyQoLVcMsEvi/4bfWQNrUoqgmYGz mUcXz/UbPuKZ2f8L9AjO97ipEoHupGEy4cwGnM5pCpnJ55ogZqcVI7Bdi8cHAvLc5adFBo/h yk6QoOdRCzhZiaE/n9BCpC48T8mk/vgqoPUUIbsIjp2SRJvVBAvgBdin/9RqoNziLBVOSvU0 T/Ji5OZYADNNwJcaDpOt/rY8ks35ZwehRtB1rAATaAT1LPhvyJNZH4vDfnZB2f1RIBSAtm7S 47rpF1u1j6xE78FU7tJo56jGqE4aua60Tum1hK6b5Ofbi1q/UTe5EqU2M00Mi+7gx3R9zx4J U4kWZaYEW/FNYWU8AgRvoUx/4iT8sSq9ZeeSUVTv/B/wGXrWHTem8syEn1mNLAH9Nt+AHtV1 dAHfWVlghCr34pawZq+Q+how8AhdYzlZdNF/H5nyj7dALAtRpWrr6fiv4cJmmdtwJoWTbCHN 5BxhTlHNHwsZzVUPlANCZUi2uKsrnb6ejxc7lmSoMLb5kCDllIrjOixabI5fPSabpRqv2Gon l7EoUbBWxMXJuWbwwSKpyfEaujnxn6iAN1DStVU7MVCi1KawikfCQYdSECgieKoj1a3HdNZM U0dvCQ0xZXe72SuR9j5Ghm6+TuK505GHdVXFOI+5UeGza+8Dxul6nYsYxVOWoQY6NEKFTUXy VG0ltLzHhxDr+jAIZ6CzYu8oTS3MCkTCGYNYy4YUAcIi+UPRqlj3nojqf4zQMaIYs3JJN3m/ 9ydQMEDa1g7iMcK0+C//wmCjWv8/N7GSQk64giRVWWghu+YWGJHT93zgbQ4xa8fRGp8crVnl CZZ8yR5xL5SZaxhbATXHI0w8EiBvp5pygH0j191BIUG/D+w4XOldo04yGghfR85bZ1cJ2O1O xa7VeZtCHl7bCvCgUhfM9LZNijW5fG7fTgYfqmIMIAUM8cvHON51HsyOR7Lt4wSrKTcufpiY M/EIJjE4YcyBqNgwz67D+Yb2vlD+8zN7TK7eHwP9Dz+ieD2TCfNF98taQLSBshntv/siFuOq L53aZDaoyizpcWkPUE7B6ZIfQ5URZX6bLiqw/FqmhmreVs7Qz9wUKKMqV7jEqQ895loei7z1 inVcidlJJDX3BUr8C3TMis7OoD8F41yt2w6NiEKNFOlkSprK4W24atVM9N9cbA7/aYxhbR5X tsUSfWmW/5vczXg/yhCTJ/fqIc5Sg+nqzjTNAWYYR8+XaVaeSr3xvHecDHSqRY+VhiMiZNmo pmL9B/qfp4YdgEzUOfUcK2Oyn2yj1g8mcVzfU3CHfdLcm6x8oIwcy3Vpd00KvEqNh/s6Ga71 QGXIBFAvsjLgdY/3+fojJC+jbWCMrVBDGsDOELE/5OaCDL8wlOz5aNhDMOZYiH7Vk7v3aepO NVu0PD3NcMYkGZws4ZTF6hhyYQ87YDNo4B24xtFHnLZSUaCEZJlf2e72PdQup13xrN2vRW8X mSN8IJ4PZSLIMbUL04DFjE6b+is1eAmpReK1K4beH7F3S5Q+KaLdW5wPBPW0SxUE+ZTAbMfm OwkvJYb1hy7hh8UKe25tyFz9VmXD3k+Qq4i54A7Aojqt1IR8Wt8Q6fgUw343JLeTO93EBgOA iSVj6/8lbhj1hL8U34sJ0Psg8tZp7oz4S5v8nFTBm60iuLkh+A21iJ/6T4YbBpY5TQZ3vNRO lpEDVxUJ6KP9QhGnMJoBnulGSxdNh+0pmnwll0DzjzfRWaVS12XfXEcOPmMzm8d4WlzbjhWx 5DG6WfHABLBXtD94Ts2YmFh88fcdN1W8hbQveyWBOGHIsUKWiXkiaqQemY4kRvrLscvjknhp +Mx3uJPRYDkFCwX+YsXNpK70OkOdRW6O2Bye/Ft06cXF2X6ejvp+zyvKVi0S/xdNc7x7k60J Mx/FP1hDy3k+n61kQkaIqoQL5tfvv0jvoMCc4y2A182ieKUqz4xva/A8iT7unQQfOxvtsQAM aLUSSOJFz2BpHlTmlKVlvJ+BEiDXYAmajH/jcePy8dYM7IYseppT1M+7avsgVWRLzlc3ky1u CHtWvbo6tJMmKVWsaniKKFhPzmPCMjSUb2I+T+jst4VYtLoN9zPhjwvqVLmHlp3OLcNautzj pCIlsD952LenbMMS2uCsYKwJ6pIwsSTXeRsLcP8KkdBrxaCQMPB5xgi+XiyDJ50zPdxw9aBf BThTuedbvsXVMV56FwPThNBAjAPD6jTRYXxlxOX9vijJEAU7l3aEYmB63TsU1B+SgYJHJ/bU SrfpPek44FjnrRmXRMrKalvPM5lHQXFR6AjStzWsAuYBEmOhnepmOPrtTgk2AHxJki0KuTIy rObeUGmbzW3gr/C8/9BuY8rvhE3Mmd0sdNtQm0joexJmxKIJ09YC98CMKc2KIBeyQ3z85DaW AvjTkUfDQfFYDAVVimkvfrCWF6TCNVbb529bnYs8liPYii7OJKYDfEzvm186nNxYX34wPvhN dga/WbqMwOsxo1yA9we/eG/nfwt08ayKqjkIqwhu5ea79ci7bQ2OLhJGQNMUWnDEZiImhybf y46QmdLREz9Qkn0eSqll7i5BzlB1A4DDR1xBctM/Dobk4qexexEjvb4PokfF5UdOd8SKudmq WzfHgOwDqP/5pDXkaQsstMtx6RzDJpn2yR8wLDLHWUvok171ojr0w7uU8bCoAHONTOzy2/gq wQ=
  • Ironport-hdrordr: A9a23:WQq/eqH6+qHl7sscpLqE0seALOsnbusQ8zAXPhZKOH5om62j5r mTdJZy73XJYVMqNU3I9urtBEDtex3hHNtOkO0s1NSZLW/bUQmTTL2KhLGKq1bd8m/Fh4lgPM xbEpSWZueeMbFSt7ee3ODBKadC/OW6
  • Ironport-phdr: A9a23:9PeYJRfp8xtZTvNCei6M/zwGlGM+cNTLVj580XLHo4xHfqnrxZn+J kuXvawr0AWYG9SAoKwcw8Pt8IneGkU4oqy9+EgYd5JNUxJXwe43pCcHRPC/NEvgMfTxZDY7F skRHHVs/nW8LFQHUJ2mPw6arXK99yMdFQviPgRpOOv1BpTSj8Oq3Oyu5pHfeQpFiCS5bL9oK Bi7owrdu8gKjYB/Nqs/1xzFr2dHdOhR2W5mP1WfkQri6Myt5pBj6SNQu/wg985ET6r3erkzQ KJbAjo7LW07/dXnuhbfQwSB4HscSXgWnQFTAwfZ9hH6X4z+vTX8u+FgxSSVJ8z2TbQzWTS/8 6dmTQLjhSkbOzIl9mzcl8p9h79Zrh28vRxy243abo+aO/VwY63TY90aS2pDUclNWCJMGZ+8Y okVAuYdIepUsYvwql0TphW+HwmsA+bvxydViHDoxqI1yf8hER3H3AM+GdIFrXLarNLvNKcTV uC10LTDwDLYb/NS3jf98onIchc9of2WWLJwddHcyUYqFwzfj1WQrZbpMC+S1uQIqmWW6fdrW u2zhWA9sQ5xviSvydk2ionPno8YxFTJ+CF9zYsoK9C1VFJ3bMKnHZZMtyyXOJV6Tt88T2xqt yg3yb0LtYKmcCUXxpoq2QLSZ+CIfYWW4x/uSvidLDFlj3xmYLKynwi+/VSkx+HmVcS50ExGo jRZntTPrHwByh/e5tafRvZ+/0qtwzSC2gHJ5u1aL004i7DXJ4Mhz7M/kJcYrFrOHivrmEXtk K+ZaF8k9PWp6+XmfLrrvoOQOolpgQ/kKKsugNawAeEgPwgOQWeb/eO82aXm/ULjQbVKiuQ6k q3bsJzHPMgbqLO1DgxL3oo55Ba/CDCm0NscnXYZNl5KZBWHj43xN1HPJvD3E+u/jkyynDt3w /3KJL7sD5XXInTdjLvsfqxx51NfxQYt1dxf4ohbCrAFIPL9QE/xs9nYAwciMwywxObnEtR91 oQCWW6VB6+ZNLjfsVCN5u01IumMYJUZtyr6K/gg//Lui2Q2lkcHfaa1xZsXdGy4HvN+LkmEe XbsmMsOEX8WvgoiS+znkEGNUTFJaHa2Rq4z+zA7CJm6AofeXYCtm6eM3Dy7H51TfmBJEEqAE Xbud4WeWvcDcjieIsF7km9Mab/0QIAo0VSitRTx1qF8BuvS4CwR85z5h/Zv4OiGrhw4/CdoD smbm0WKVWBzgitcXDsxxqF4vQp4zn+M1KF5h7pTEtkFtKABaRszKZOJl78yMNv1QA+UJr9hK X6jS9SiWnQqS84phsQJewB7EsmjiRbK22yrBaUUnvqFHs986brSil72Ics10HPazO85lVBzW c9IL2yhmuh68yDcAofIlwOSkKP5Pb8E0nv1/XyYhXGLoFkeVQdxVavfWnVKfU/Rt9X++gXHS 5ehDL0mNk1KzsvRYrBSZIjPilNLDOzmJMyYY2+1nDKoAg2Uw7qXcIfwU2AU3SGYDEpd1g5Kr SzAOg85CSOs5WnZCVSCDHrJZEXhual7oXK/FQovyh2SKlZmz/yz8wIUgvqVT7US2KgFsWEvs Wc8GlH1xN/QB9eawmgpNKxBfdMw5ktG3mPFpkR8OJKnNaVrml8ZdUx+oUrv0xx9DogIn9Itq Tsmyw97KKTQ110kFXvQxpT3ILzQNi/3+DigbqfX3hfV19PXsqYD5fIkqkny6RmzHxlq+HFm3 t9JlnqEs8+SXUxCDNSrChZxrkgg9NS4KmEn6ojZ1GNhK/yxuz7GgJcyAfc9jw2nZ5FZOb+FE wn7F4sbAdKvIaokgQvMDFpMMeZM+aozJ87jeeGB3fvhJ+JnhjOhkSJC5Khy10uN82x3TeuCj PNni7mImxCKUTvxlgLrqcTwg4FDeXcXGkKwzCHlAMhaYag4LuNpQS++ZsawwNt5nZvkXXVVo UWiC10x08isYROOblb50GW8zGwvqGe80Wu9xj1wyHQyq7aHmTfJ26LkfQYGPWhCQC9ji03tK M66lYJSUE+tZgkv3ByrgCSyj7Nfo75+KHWVRENgcC3/LmUkWay1/raPeM9A7po0vD4fCrztJ wDHDOSl811Dg3mrFnAW3D0hcjC2ppj1+n4ywHmQKnp+tjuReM19wwve+M2JQPdQ2jQcQywrw TLTB1W6I5yo5YDOz8aF4r34DTrxEMQDK3qOr8vIriaw6Gx0DAfqmvmynoaiCg0myWrg0MEsU yzUrRH6a42t1qKgMOshcFM7YT20o8d8BIx6lZM9wZ8K3n1PzI6R+mAGlnu1NNFz1qf3bX5LT jkOiY2wgkCtyAh4I3SFypisHG6ZxdFgYMX8Z2c+1Sc07sQMA6CRpu8h/2M9sh+zqgTfZuJ4l zEWxK416XIUtOoOvRIk0iSXBr1BVVkdJyHnkA6EqsyvtKgCLnj6aqC+jQAt+LLpRKHHuAxXX 2z1P4svDTMlpNsqK0rCiTXy8t22I4SWNINL8EfIzFGYyLIJYJMpyqhU2Ww9Yjm75CN9jbZ81 E0Lv9nyvZDbeTszuvvhWFgAcGWyPZtb+ymx3/gA2JzKjsb/RtM5XW9TFJrwEaD3SnRL6bK+Z lzISHpl+hL5UfLeBVPNtxsg9iiSVcjtbzbOejEY1YkwHUHNYhUA30ZEGm19xMdxFxj2lpW+K wEgt2xXvhig7UISr4AgfxjnDjWF/FbuOmpyEcLPakIRt14K5l+JY5bHsKQuT2cBr8fn9EvUe ySaf1gaVzhXHBbfVha4ZP/2ooCRlorQTvy3K/+ECVmXgcpZUfrAhZem0489ui2JKt3KJX56S fsyxktEW3l9XcXfgTQGDSINxWrLaIaAqRGw9zcSzIj3+en3WA/p+YqECqdDedRp9ReshK6fN umWzC9nIDdc35kIyDfG0r8alFIVjihvcXGqH9Fi/WbVS7nMn6ZMExMBQyZ6Nc8N66BlmwcUa ZSdhdTy2bp1yPUyDhYNVFDsnN2oed1fI2y5MwCiZg7DP7CHKDvXhsDvNPnkGPsA0aMO70324 GbBQCqBdnyZmjLkVg6iK7RJhSCfZ1lFvZ2lNw1qES7lRc7nbRuyNJl2iyc3yPs6nCCvVyZUP D5ifkdKtrDV4zlfh6A1AGhG9HtiMa+Bnw6W6uDZLtAdtv4hUUEW36pKpW83zbdY9nQOXPtuh C7btcJjuXmjm+iLjz5lCV9A82YRwo2MukpmNOPS8ZwKChOmtFodqG6XDRoNvd5sDNbi7rtRx tb4n6X2MD5e8tjQ8KP04uDbLcuGNDwqNh+7QFY84yMKSDeqMSfUgEkPyZl6F1WQp5k+75zuw d8AE+8BElMyEfweBwJuG9lQeP9K
  • Ironport-sdr: 65fa985b_XuclnA9w6E/wN+hI0CvjgSbBAGLL29wi9cSDwNjSubWZ1qi JB3XBBTzGNDfMkbCEOqEhSmVCUHIbeZlvSbbleQ==

If you do not allow the addition of new points nor move of existing
points, then there is no way a sliver could be removed from Delaunay
as it is uniquely defined given a set of points.

What are you allowed to do with your point set?

Best,

Sebastien.

On 3/11/24 11:48, Justice Temiloluwa Olatunbosun wrote:
Dear Sir/Madam,

I am Justice Olatunbosun, a master student of mechanical engineering and a scientific assistant of computational mechanics at the Dortmund Technical University, Germany.

I am currently using the CGAL library in research areas applied to generating finite element meshes. Currently, most of my work has been in two dimensional space with the CGAL 2D delauanay tessellations with much success. By demand, I am required to make extensions to three dimensional space as well. However, the CGAL 3D delauanay triangulation is not sufficient alone in itself to generate usable finite element meshes for my work due to the presence of slivers.

CGAL, offers the option to refine and optimize mesh which removes slivers, but this option is only available to the "CGAL::Mesh_triangulation_3::type" which requires a domain definition in its creation. For my work, I only intend to provide vertex coordinate of the Point_3 as input and as such, only the "Delaunay_triangulation_3.h" works for me. I am currently unable to find sliver treatment for direct CGAL 3D triangulation in the documentation manual. I would like to find out if this option is available somewhere via CGAL or what other methods are available to generate meshes from only coordinates of vertices and then refined against slivers.

I would appreciate your kind feedback.

Best Regards
Justice Olatunbosun




Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.

Top of Page