Subject: CGAL users discussion list
List archive
- From: "????" <>
- To: "cgal-discuss" <>
- Subject: Re: [cgal-discuss] about arc in cgal arrangement
- Date: Tue, 1 Jul 2025 16:15:30 +0800
- Authentication-results: mail3-smtp-sop.national.inria.fr; spf=None ; spf=Pass ; spf=None
- Ironport-data: A9a23:8a+AyakV8x0KMoJZnfnWASfo5gz0LURdPkR7XQ2eYbSJt16W5oE/e lBvW2iPP4uNZGWFCKtwG/+/9jsYu5Tcx9BgTgpy92liJ54hgZXOVNnCdxuuZHzCI5OZF0g7v s5EMtKdIJ0+EyKD/UugPuDqoHUkhKjRH7ehBL+eYyt8FV4+Fi5+gE0+lrJm09QAbbRVY++ok YqaT5r3ZgT7i2cc3hso1p++RDNTUNXa4zpD5VZva64b5VGHyHBIUJ9EdKjrcCGoHoNfQLfkT LfqweDi9As13T99U4L/yu6Tnm4iG+OJY1DW0hK6f4D433CucwRriv5T2MI0MBsR0XPT9zxI4 I0lnYSqTgs0NbH7lu0YUh1JewlzJqQuFIXveBBTiuTNiRSYG5fQ6682VhxuYtVBor8f7Vxmr JT0FhhdNnhvuMrtmNpXesE07uw/Ic/iOp8ou30I5Vk12t57KXxra/yiCe5whF/ctOgWdRrtT 5ZxhQ5UUfj1S0Yn1mH7p34JtLzAanHXK1W0ob8OzEY9yzC7IAdZiNABPDdJEzAjqAo8ckuw/ wr7E2rF7h4yZduc5yag8UiQhMDmpDzrYJgfBqyBz6s/6LGT7jR75Bw+RV6xrvm61Qi7UtNbb VUNvCEpqMDe9mT3FZ+kAUb++STU+EJDMzZTO7VSBAWlkPeKu1nBXjBdFRZYcZots8peqTkCj wXRxI25XmUz2FGTYX255oiTkmuOBQQuCFdfVAtbQCIX3/C29enfiTqUEosyTfft5jHvIhn7z DmO6SQ/nL4OltUjzLS+5VmBgjS2p5GPQBRd2+nMdnKg5Ax5Z9HjYoWp7R7C9LBLK4PxokS9U GYsys+dwvwrDquxlgOkefodJKuk9ee8CWiJ6bJwJKUJ+zOo8n+lWIlf5jBiOUtkWvronxe3P ic/XisPuvdu0GuWUENhX26mI/8FpZUM+Pz1U/rbbtkRJJ14dQvB5TgobkmVt4wMrKTOuf9kU Xt4WZ/2ZZr/NUiB5GbtLwv6+eNyrh3SPUuJGfjGI+2PiNJynkK9R7YfK0epZesk9q6Cqwi92 48AapLRk0UECLCmOXO/HWsvwbYiciNT6Xfe9JU/SwJ/ClA8cI3cI6aIne1xK9QNc1p9xrmRo SzVtrBkJKrX3iGaeFjTMhiPmZvmVpthrHY/MGQ0IVvu32QvJ+6SAFQ3KfMKkU0c3LU7l5ZcF qFbE+3ZW6QnYmqcoVw1M8KixKQyLETDuO57F3H8CNTJV8U5H1SRkjIlFyOznBQz4t2f7Jdv+ uD9iliAH/LuhW1KVa7rVR5m9Hvp1VB1pQ64dxKgzgB7KRSwort5YTf8lOE2KMwqIBDOjGnSn QWPDBtS4aGHr4Yp+ZObzeqJvqW4IdtYR0B6Jmj86arpFC/4+mH4/5RMftzVdh/gVUT12p6YW 8Nr89/GPsYqpm1667hHL+4zzIYVxcfemLtB/wE1QFTJdwuKD51jEFmn3O5OlL1G/eJbs1HuW 2ak2NpTCZOWMuzLTX8TIwsEaLyY9Pc2wzP909U8EH/Y1gRWooWVdFp0BAadrhBSN51JCZMV+ vggs8so9ACPsBomHdKYhCRy9W7XDHg/f4g4l5MdWqnHtxEKzwxcXJniFSPG2pGDRNFSOE0MI DXPpq7jhaxZ93XSYUgICnnB8upMt6sg4CkQ4gc5GG2Ivd7Zitsc/h5bq203RzsI6CR36bt4P 2wzOnBlIamLwSxTu/FCeGKRACBEOgyS/x3g6lkOlVCBdXKSaE72EDQfN9qOrWcjyEANWhhA/ bqd9nTpbiayQuH1wRkJeBBEr97NcIVP0zPsyeGdItS9PpglYDDarLekSkgWpjDGX84gpk31i tN73eR3aKDUbC8i+a0hLZjHyYUvTAugIkJSZfRH4qkyPHr9fQuq0mOkMHGBecJqJt3L/3SnC sdoGNl9ahSm2AuKrREZHaQpMZYsuNIM+/w5ZaLNGWEdlYemvgpSr5Pb8xbhiF8RQ9lBldg3L qXTfWmgFlO8qGR1mWiXiuV5IUu9PMc5YTPj0NCP8OkmE4wJtMduexoQ1pq2p3CkDxt1zSmLv Q/sZ77k8MI68N5Cx7DTK6RkAxm4DfjRV+7SqQC6jIloXOP1aMzLs1sYl0njMwFoJoAuYtVQl 4mWkdvJzUjA7acXUWfYpsG7LJN3x/6OBchZDsGmC0Nhv3qmeNTt6B496WyHOcR3sNdC1PKGG Sq8SuWNLOAwZfkM6kFRWSZkFzQlN5/WdYbl/CO0kOSNAEMS0CvBN9KWykXqZmB6KA4OFY3aD ynqsc2P/fFdlpxHXzUfNsFlArh5AV7tYrQnfNvPrgulDnGkr1eBm7n6nz8ywGjvJljdN+3lu LTpaBTaXzajipHild12ndR7gUwKMSxbn+I1QHM4x/d3rDKLVEg9MuUXNMQ9OKF+yyDd+snxW 2DQUTEEFy74YDVjdCf86vTFWiO0JLQHGvX9FwwT03KkUQWEL6LeP+I57QZl2Wl8RRX7xuL+K d0+xGz5DiLs/r5XH9Qs9t6JqsY54MjFx0A421H3yO3zJBc8PY8k9lJcGCh1aCiWNP2VyWvqI zE5S1kRFQv/AQT0HN17cnFYJAABsXm9h380ZCOI25DEt5/d0OREz+blNvru1qEYKv4HP6MKW Wi9Ul7lD7p6AZDPkfBBVxMVba5I5TajDs2wI6/gGksXlqC0rH0+ecgFmELjiS3kFBF3Szvge vuEuhDSx3hp7GhIwfudzgBhF1dZTCcXFz+Q5OLgjWaurPH6puQ1vzCz1UTwLpSYR20PealHa G96UXt9aGF6eNcpSfeSexjbSpG67RktKET5
- Ironport-hdrordr: A9a23:NSdMcKDaz2jTrSzlHem755DYdb4zR+YMi2TDtnoQdfU7SKalfq yV8cjztiWUtN9yYh4dcLm7UcHqfZq2z/BICPwqTNKftX7dyQ+Vxe9ZgbcKuweQeREWodQttp tdTw==
- Ironport-phdr: A9a23:2+fJEhV9RwSaBXW3+ujvZ6Z/ORbV8KzXXDF92vMcY1JmTK2v8tzYM VDF4r011RmVBt6ds6kP0raO7uigATVGvc3b9ihaMdRlbFwst4Y/p08aPIa9E0r1LfrnPWQRP f9pcxtbxUy9KlVfA83kZlff8TWY5D8WHQjjZ0IufrymUoHdgN6q2O+s5pbdfxtHhCanYbN1M R66sRjdutMZjIZsJKs90AfFr3VHd+hLym5kOVKelAv46sus4ZJv6Stdtvw/+8JaTan2Y6E0R qFEATo7NGw4+MLkuR7fQAWV4XcSTnsYmQdSDQjf6xH6UJbxsi/kued4xSKXI874Q60qVDq79 6tkRwPmhykBNz4i7WHYkddwg75BoBKgvBNw3YjZa5yIOfVkf6PdedQaRXddXstUSidMDJ+wY 5cJAuEcOulWspT9p0AWrRSgGQasGO3hyjhNhnDs3K061fkqHQXJ0QEkGt4DtnPbosn1OqoMS Oy51bfFzTLFb/NKxzj97pTIfA4hoPGUQ718b9faxU0hGg/Zi1mdr5HuMTGI2eQXq2Wb7uhvV eyvhWA5tg9+rSSgyMgihIfThYwbzUvJ9T97zosvP9C3RlJ3bMSiHZBNty+aLYx2QsY6Tm1mu iA+0LIDv4e1cCMXz5kr2R7SZv2bf4WK/h7vSPqdLSp2iX9+YbK/ngy+/lSnyu35T8S51ktBo SVZnNfWrH8NywDT5dadSvt75kqv1zaC2g/N5+9KL045l6TWJp88z7M+l5cdsVnPEzL4lkj0g 6GbdEcp9/S15unnbbjrp4ORO5JphwzwMqkihsOyDOIlOQYAWGib/P6z1Lzl/UDhWbVKl+c6n bXesJDfPcgbv6q5Awha0oYk8RqwEzGm3MwZnXkBNlJFeQiIg5LnO1HUJv3zEPSxg0y0nTpky f3KJKDtD5TDI3TZjbvtY7Vw51RTxQcx1dxT+YxYB78bLP7uREP9rsLUAx82PgCu3urqCtdw2 4UDUm+RBq+ZLbjSsUOW6eI1PueMZY4UtyjlJvQ54fPlkGU3lkUHfaaz2JsacHC4EepiI0Wee XftjdIBHnwFvgo+T+znikeOUTtJaHazW6Iw/Cg7CJu8AYjfQYCthaSN3Ca9HpJIemBLEl+BH Hnye4mZWvoBZjieLtJ/njEHT7SsRI0s2QmrtADgyrpnKuTU+jcftZLmzNV5+e3emBAu+TF2E 8iRz32BQ3x6k24TXj82xbpzrlB6yleGyaR4hedXGsRJ5/xVSgc6KYLcz+tiBtzvQg7BZMuGS E66QtW6BjE8Vs4+w9AUbEZ5AtmtkxHD3zG2DL8IjLyLH4c58rnc3nj0P8Zy0WzK1Kgnj1k8Q 8tAL3eqhqBl91ubOojSjk/Ml7q2bb9Om2nW5WKbxCyPultZWUh+S+LeTHUHbwzXq9r+oUjNR rvrBbU8ORZa0p2/LLBXYP31iFETROv/IM+MJCWqimKoDFCJwKmNZczkYSIGzSDFAQ8FlQ4Uu n2JPAx7Cia6qH/FF29TE0nyaX/h4fUrqG+nVlRmiEaRfkh53vy0/AQUjLqSUbQIz7ccsWAgr TtzW12y1taTB9ubrBd6Z/ZgZoZ361hO0SfVthd2I4e7Zeg2jVEXd0F7vljlyg5sIoRGi8kj6 n0wmllcM6WdhRn5qecnl9ikYOCJcjaqpEj2MIbPwxfV19PAqfRH0+gxt1i25FLhLUEl6Xgyj Ig9Oxq045zLCFFXSpftSgMs8AA8objGYy477oeS1Ht2MKDyvCWRk8kxCr4DzRCtN8xaLLvCD BX7RpdHWZDxcLRywgOBdwtCN+dXp+YvJ83zT/Kdw+awOfp42jevjGBJ+od4hxjRqXIjEraQh s0t2uje1QyCBH/nlFn0lMfxlMhfYC0KWGqyzS+xHIlKeqh7ZpoGE0++Jse4xtYhwZvkWnoe7 UflDFQDsCOwUTyVaVG1nQhZ1EBM5GeihTP91Dts1TcgsquY2iXKheXkbhsOfGBRFiFkih/3L I64gsp/PgDgZhU1lBaj+UfxxrRK7KV5IW7JRE5Ufi/wZ2h8W6q0v7CGboZB8pQt+SlQVe29Z xidRNuf61NAjn27QDMGnGlgXyiz/J7+ml0yiW6QKmpysGuMYdt5ll/U4N3RQ+IU3yJTGHI+0 GeMQAHmb5/1oobx9d+LqO21WmO/W4cGdCDqydjFry6n/ShxBgX5mfmvm9rhGAx80Cnh1tAsW z+byXS0KoTtyam+NvpqO0dyA1qpoZAnRNkhytNo3co4wGFcjZKQtyli8y+7IZBA1KTyYWBYD 2RWnYaKuFC9gRZLN2vPzIX8HCbV0o5qYN+0ZXkT0yQ24pVRCaua27dDmDN8vluyqQ+5jeFVp j4G0rNu7Xcbh7pMow8x1mCGBahUG0BEPCvqnhDO7takrawRanz9ObS30UN/m5imAtTg6kkGB SihJc96RXYrxtxmdlnL1TX/55rld9/Zcd8I/kHP1U6e1K4McsJ3yqVCjDEvIW/nuHw51+M36 H4mlYq3uoSKMSQl/a60BAJZKiygYsoS/j/3iqMN1s2S3o2pAtBgAmBXB92xE6nuSWhC86i4Z GPsWHUmp3yWGKTSB1qa4UZi9DfUFoyzcmqQPD8fxMljQx+UIApehhoVVXM0hM1cdEjiycr/f UN+/j1U6ET/r04GkL82b0anCj+G/y+xc3E/T53Vf380pklSolzYN8CT9Lc5RXwGpsL59FTUc USCfkJDCmRDCQSUQlvkOLep/9zJ9eOVU/G/I/X5arKLseVCVv2MyMHKsMMu73OWO86IJHUnE +wj1x8JQyViA8qA0WZHW2kNminKdcLeuBqs5ng9sJWk6PqyPWCnrYqXV+kLaI4pokjmx/bZc bbX3nsxKC4EhMpWnDmRlP5AgxhKzHszPzi1TeZQ7GiTHeSKw/ARVkBcMXMWVoMA7rpgjFUWf 5eF0ZWsjO4+0qZyUQYNVES9yJ3yI5VUeCfkbgOBWBbMbuXOJCWXkZyrJ/riFfsJ0bwS7kPq3 FTTWwrqOjDJ/9XwfzaoN+wEzCSSPRgF/Zq4bg4oEm/7CtTvdhy8NtZzyzww27w9wH3QZyYaN nBnfkVBo6f1j2sQi+hjG2FH8ntuLPWV0yef4e7CL58KsPxtSi1qnuNe6X4+xvNb9iZBDPByn SLTqJZprTTE2qGXzSF7VRNVtjtRrJKOt0piOvqf85BBXTDd5VQG6mDRQxUGqt15C8H+7qBdz t+c8cC7YDxG8t/S4Y4dH52Ic4TebiFnaEC5XmKLX25nBXaxOGrShlJQiqSX/3yR9d0hr4T03 YEJUvldXUA0EfUTDgJkGsYDKdF5RGBB8/bTgcgW6H65tBSUSt9du8WNDK/MWaq3cG7A1pFdf l0DxrayfuFxfsXrnldvbFV3htGAA03LQdVEuTFsdCckpU9C8HshCGg62kajcxrr63gWX63R/ FZ+mk51ZuIj8y3p6lE8Kw/RpSc+p0I2nM3snTGbdDOZxEaYTYRcBCr36A40O5L/BR9sKwa1m B48XN8rb6tIybBncDIy4Oc5kYJWX/VbSP8cCCI=
- Ironport-sdr: 6863992a_YeKJYvSzcJ5Qxl1CRlJ+7K7umONNgxNn7uRdeC1bPbh1XwJ YMukEJZK5PgAoX81LLXUG11HU3YFF/zIzJGPD5Q==
"Thank you very much, although I have already solved this problem.
I looked through the official help documentation, but I never managed to find how to handle precision issues. It only explains the principles, but I couldn't find any solutions or practical examples on how to deal with it.
Straight lines are manageable, but for arcs or circles, in the official examples, the endpoint coordinates appear to use rational numbers. Even the radii seem to have specific requirements; they aren't given directly as floating-point numbers. I feel this is almost impossible to achieve in real-world projects, where floating-point numbers are generally used. Yet, I couldn't find any information on how to properly handle this.
In the end, I approximated the arcs and circles with line segments. Working with straight lines in CGAL Arrangements seems to be reliable and error-free in calculations."
I submitted three straight lines and one circular arc to the CGAL Arrangement, as shown in the left figure. The final calculation result, shown in the right figure, is incorrect. However, if I discretize the arc into line segments, the result becomes correct. so how to do .
--
You are currently subscribed to cgal-discuss.
To unsubscribe or access the archives, go to
https://sympa.inria.fr/sympa/info/cgal-discuss
- Re: [cgal-discuss] about arc in cgal arrangement, Efi Fogel, 07/01/2025
- Re: [cgal-discuss] about arc in cgal arrangement, Nicklas SB Karlsson, 07/08/2025
- Re: [cgal-discuss] about arc in cgal arrangement, Efi Fogel, 07/09/2025
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: [cgal-discuss] about arc in cgal arrangement, ????, 07/01/2025
- Re: [cgal-discuss] about arc in cgal arrangement, Nicklas SB Karlsson, 07/08/2025
- Re: [cgal-discuss] about arc in cgal arrangement, Nicklas SB Karlsson, 07/08/2025
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.