coq-club AT inria.fr
Subject: The Coq mailing list
List archive
- From: Michael Soegtrop <MSoegtrop AT yahoo.de>
- To: coq-club AT inria.fr
- Subject: Re: [Coq-Club] Question about ATPs in CoqHammer
- Date: Sat, 12 Feb 2022 10:53:12 +0100
- Authentication-results: mail2-smtp-roc.national.inria.fr; spf=None smtp.pra=MSoegtrop AT yahoo.de; spf=Pass smtp.mailfrom=msoegtrop AT yahoo.de; spf=None smtp.helo=postmaster AT sonic302-21.consmr.mail.ne1.yahoo.com
- Ironport-data: A9a23:VB2fWK5jJIVI8o/LBX+WSgxRtLLBchMFZxGqfqrLsTDasY5as4F+v jFOXW6DPfqPN2H2fY9xatjno0gOscXXx4JnTgZurik9Zn8b8sCt6faxfh6hZXvKRiHgZBs6t JtGMoGowOQcFCK0SsKFa+C5xZVE/fjUAOK6UYYoAwgpLeNeYH5JZSlLxqhp0uaEvfDjW1nX4 Ymr+ZWGULOY82cc3lw8u/rrRCxH56yaVAMw5jTSstgW1LN2vyB94KM3fcldHVOgKmVnNrLSq 9L48V2M1jixEyHBpT+Suu2TnkUiGtY+NOUV45Zcc/DKbhNq/kTe3kunXRYRQR8/ttmHozx+4 MRGkcO5ZyQmBauSyMYjUDBHHQ9cF7ITrdcrIVDn2SCS51bBdXrnmK00SRtve4Yf/P1yGydL/ P0cbjYAN1aSjuKxx/SwTewEasYLcpetZd1E/Cgwk3eAUalOrZPrG80m4fddxzA9idxUGu72d sMZbj0pYBmojxhnYA5PUcllwb3Aan/XYztg82+2o/QN02HpiwBgjqDPYcLMU4nfLSlSth3C+ Dibpj2R7gshHNeY0H+O9m+mrvTemDvyHoMUDryxsPBw6GB/3UQIDxsXXgDj+7zj0wi1XNREL lZS/yMvqe40+RXtX9D9WBr+q3mB1vIBZzZOO/wxzF6E5Inb2ADHVko6TRdeZvIEntBjEFTGy WS1t9/uADVutpicRnSc6qqYoFuO1c49cjFqicgsElVt3jXznG0gpk6WFIg6ScZZmvWwSGyhm G3WxMQrr+xL1ZZj6kmtwbzQb9tATLDuSwc17207tUr7vlooO+ZJi2FEgGU3AN5bK4CYRQLZ5 j1ewo6V6+YVCIvLkSWMRKMLEejv9v+FNzqaillqd3XAy9hP0yH9FWyzyGsmTKuMDiriUWKyC KM0kV4KjKK/xFPwMcdKj3uZUqzGN5TIG9X/TezzZdFTeJV3fwLv1HgwORLOhzy3yBByyvxX1 XKnnSCEUi1y5UNPk2Heegvh+eVDKt0WmTyCHMCjn3xLL5LDOy7MIVv6DLd+RrtjsvnZ+Vy9H yd3MMKWy11fV+nyYy/Y6uYuwaMichAG6WTNg5UPLIare1I4cEl4UqO56e5/J+RNwvsN/s+Vr ynVchIJkzLX2CyXQS3UMSsLQO20Av5CQYcTZnBE0aCAgCV7Pe5CLc43K/MKQFXQ3LI/k6AkF aRZEyhCa9wWIgn6F/0mRcGVhORfmN6D3Gpi5gKpP2oyeYBOXQvM9oO2dwfj7nlcHyO3ssx4r 7D5jlHXRp8KRgJDCsfKaavzng3r4iVHwLp/DxnSP91eWETw64w2eSb/ufk6fpMXIhLZyzrGi gubWE9KpeTEr4Iv3sPOgKSI89WgH+dkThhLFmnc6vC6OHCCrGakxIZBVseOfCzcDT+lpv/9O L8Nl/ylaa8JhldHtYZ4Ao1H96Nm6ou9vaJewyRlAG7PMwahBIRmLyTUxsJIrKBMmuJUtAbqC EKC/t5WZeeANM//SwFDPw0jb+/YjatRwGCU5vMzO0Dgoip+/b7BV0gLeQiFiCtaarByNdp9k +smvccX7S25iwYrbYfe0ngJrTzUIyxSSbgju7EbHJTv1Vgmx1REVprWVX377ZSJXNNTPxR4O TSTnqfD2+9RyxaQaXY1DnSRj+NRiY5V50JRy1kDLA/RwJ+f37k82xtK9C5xSw1UylNB3rs1K 2FrMEozLqKLpm86iM9GVmGqOgdAGBzGqxStkwZTzDXUHxuyS2jADGwhIuLSrk0U9mRreDIEr ryVzWDSVynnIZPq1SwoVE858PHuQLSdLOEZdBxLwihEI3U7XdYhqrSpY2sD8EO9RJlowkbAo /Jv5qB1YKz/cygd+usqAomd0vIbTxXsyKmuhx1+1PthII0eUGjaNfuyx4SZa8pNIPuM/ULQ5 wlGOJdUTxrnvMqRhmlzOEPPSoOYWNY47doFffXnKAbqdldZQiVB6Prty8Q1uIPnrxiCXyrwx kM9ug9uylCtuEY=
- Ironport-hdrordr: A9a23:XWQlt6hBT/csNDTjQEVxjzn3dXBQXicji2hC6mlwRA09TyXqrb HLoN0w0xjohDENHFQtnt6cOcC7MA/hHPlOkPMs1NaZLXLbUQ6TR72KgrGD/9SNIVyGygcZ79 YZT0EcMqySMbEZt6fHCWCDer5OruVvsprY49s2pE0dKD2CBZsQiDuRRjzrcHGePDM2eKYRJd 6nwO1mjX6MW1QyKv6aKF5tZYL+juyOrpTgYRRDIzFP0mWzZWfB0tPHLyQ=
- Ironport-phdr: A9a23:o+BEWBNvceieY5+8uVol6nadBhdPi9zP1u491JMrhvp0f7i5+Ny6Z QqDv68r0gKCBdqTwskHotKei7rnV20E7MTJm1E5W7sIaSU4j94LlRcrGs+PBB6zBvfraysnA JYKDwc9rDm0PkdPBcnxeUDZrGGs4j4OABX/Mhd+KvjoFoLIgMm7yf6+94fSbghIizaxfbF/J wiqoAvMscUbnZFsIbsrxBvTpXtIdeVWxWd2Kl+Wgh3x+MS+8oN9/ipJo/4u+NJOXqv8f6QjU LxXFy8mPHwv5M3qrhbMUw2C7WYBX2oMkxpIBw/F7AzmXpr0ryD3uPZx1DWcMMbrS70/RDas4 LpxSBLwiykJOTE2/2/KhMJugqJVoBCuqABwzYDTe4yVKPhzc7nBcd4AS2dMXMBcXDFBDIOma IsPCvIMM+FZr4bhp1sBtwWxBQ2xD+3yzT9HmHD23bEg0+QmCQHNwQstEdUTvnTTstr1O7sSU fqyzKnQ1jjCb+lZ2Tf66IjPaBwuvO+DUKt2fMHMxkYhCxnLgU+MqYz5ITyVzOINvnCG4+Z9V u+ihG4ppx9xrzWs2ssgl4bHi54Ux17L6Sl0z4g4KcO3RkNnbtOpDZtduz+EOodqX84vQ31lt Sk7x7ACv5OwYSYEyJMixxHFavyHdZCF4h3iVOaNITd4mWlqdKijiBa19Eis0uz9VtSw0FZLt ipKjtnMuWoR1xDJ9seHTf5980G80jiMzwDe8uBJLEEumabGKpMszKQ8mocQvEnCBCP6hUr7g a2Qe0454Oan8f7nba/jppKEN497lAX+MqM2l8ykBuQ4NAkOUHSV9OigyrHv5FP1TKhQgvIql anZtovaJcEBpqKjBg9ayIcj6xKlAzegztsUgGMLLVJfdxKHiIjpPEvCL+z/Dfe6m1iskTFry O7aPrD5A5jAL2LPnKrgcLtz8UJQ1Qk+wNFF655JBbwMIur/Wkrru9zZCh85PRa0w+HiCNhl0 4MeQmWPDbGWMKPOq1+I4fovLvKMZYAPuDb9LP8l6+TzgnAngVMde7Km0oMNaH+kBvRmP1mZY X30j9scCWsKpBYxTPT2iF2eVj5ef2q9X6Ul5j0iFI2mCZrDSZu2jbya3Ca7G4VWaXpcBlCNF 3fobYSEVO0WZCKcOM8y2gADALOmUsoq0QyknA780btuaOTOqQMCspe28dl+5+TekVkJ8jF7E 96ayynZalpzk2wUXTgu9LF2oUt6jFuOh/sry8dEHMBesqsaGjwxMoTRmrQS47HaXwvAeo3MU 1O6WpC8Bjp3SNstwtgIakI7GtO4jxmF0TD5S6QNmemtA5o5urnZw2C3P9x0nlP906Quk0MhW uNePG2hgehz+lubHJbHxn2QjL3ibqEAxGjI/WaHw3CJuRRdSwl9XrnfWmg3d0LWqtO/6k6RB 6S2B+EBNQ1MgdWHNrMMatDtigBeQ+z/Pd3Ff2+rs3y3AxeDnevWKdCzPW4a2j7YEg4BmgEXu 3CLbE4vDyempCTVCzkG+UvHRUTq/KE+rXq6ShVx1ASWdwh70LHz/BcJhPuaQvdV37QeuS5np S8mVFC6l8nbDdaNvW8DNO1VfM897VFb1GnYqx01P5quKLpnj0IfdAI/tl3n1hF+AIFN2cYwq 3ZiwA13IKOemFRPElHQlbXLPbDYNnP15Di+Yq7R3RfS3Zfe+6sC7ug5t0S2pBugRQIp93Rq1 cUQ0mPJuMuMVVRJF8uhDABuq0cpwtOSKjMw7I7Vy3B2ZKy9szuYnsksGPNg0BGrOdFWLKKDE gb2VcwcHcmnbuIwyD3LJloJOv5f8KksMoaobfyDjeSuJ+Ftky68inxv8Yl91UXK+yc2GYuql 94VhuqV2AeKTWK2qWymv8/rg4dcTSAbHm24jyTpTt0Zduh5eoAFDn2rKsu8y4BlhpLjbHVf8 UaqG1IM3MLBlQO6V1XmxkUQ0E0WpSbigi6k13lulDpvqKOD3SvIyuCkdRwdO2cNSnMwxVvrJ IG1iZgdUi3KJ0Asjxyo6lrgwLBzta1/KG6VTUoAcyXtLm5kW7e9rfLcPYgWtshu6HUJFr3gP hiTUfblrgEf0j//Emc7pnhzbDystpjj3lR7hG+bMHdvvS/ccMB0yw3Y4Y+UTvpQ0zwaAShg3 GeJQAHiZJ/wrYvSzsuc4YXcHyq7W5ZecDfm19aFvSq/vyhxBAGn2uq0kZvhGBQ71iny059rU z/JpVDyeNqOtezyPOR5c01vHFK55dB9H9Q0l5A3iZ4Mw38CroSc/X0A12v+e4Y+u+q2fD8WS DgHzsSAqg3+30BsMmiO36roX3WaxY1tapPpKnNT0SU74cdQDa6S57ERhip5rG2zqgfJaOR8l DMQmp5MoDYKxvsEsw03wmCBE6gfSANGaDf0mU3CvJiu6b9ab2G1ff2s2VpiyJq/WaqarFgUQ GrjKIYrHSh3qM54NTeumDXr9pu2adDQatVVsBCI20DJi+wfQH4ovtwNgycveWf0vHl/jvU+k QQrx5ax+o6ON2Rq+qu9RB9eLDz8Ic0JqHnriu5Fk8Ca0prKfN0pEygXXJbuUfOjES4D/fXhO QGUFTQgq3CdUbPBFA6b4U1iojrBCZeuf32QIXAYy51lSnz/bARHhxsIWTwhgpMjPhutws3qK x8jo2pIoFX/rABJ0KRtPhj7FGHS/UG5YzczT96UKx8Xi2MKr0bZPMqC7/5iSiFV+pry5AeJK 2Gde0FJFTRXBArdWQulZ+nwo4CcrLv9ZKL2NfbFbLSQpPYLUv6JwcjqyY5653OWMc7JOHB+D vo9004FXHZjGs2flS9cLk5f3y/LccOfow+xvyNtqcXquvHwXw/g+ZGIE5NDONVo/Fa6jO3QU ozYzDY8Mjte2p4WkDXQz6MD2VcJlyx0XyKqF7UL7naXCfiJ3KRQCQUecWV2PcpMqaQxh09cM M7cjZX+0bsy3ZtXQx9VEFfmnM+uf8kDJWqwYUjGCEi8P7ODPTTXwsvzbMtUppVBheVTsFu8t GTCe6cGFiWKlz7uERyiY7kkZMCzJxtYuYrmKkwoUzGlR9XgcRihdtp+jDlwx7BtwGLDNWkbd zN7dhEVxoA=
- Ironport-sdr: ZyKD8hFKcm3Npw3noZwtztvKAyFcDIk2tQZdycqu/xtPb+p70P4WAY8tAPmJYwydirMJrNb+GV qxe+TbdXCcZnEX8L6qrffHBEK5KMwkEYF1fJD/IowWhNC+gIn02ZBbluHF/AUpL+83ImSNXuet 5K0TnQGv3m9hTBTNt+qiPB4U4pr/6t8a/nU0abQGfFQIiSrmaFL2w3z0gKsAPTY+8YfVjV+iM7 2hWX4uGqDwyxo9c84HuTNaT+xHX5pG7/7cXDC594uWAiBjHX4dCpbDWEbw2YrhK53OKPWqoo6e mAzUKLF8KmPS+ZquWqzYP9dH
Dear Richard,
the 2022.01 release of Coq Platform for Coq 8.14 and 8.15 does include Coq Hammer with E-prover and Z3-tptp. Both ATPs are installed as opam packages and compiled from sources. This is tested daily in Coq Platform CI on all supported OSes and works.
I am working on adding CVC4 and Vampire, but it takes time. I want to create opam packages for these, so that one gets a well defined version independent of OS. IMHO these tools are too rare to rely on system package managers for them. One issue with CVC4 is that it has Java dependencies, which is not nice in opam, but possibly I can rely on system package managers for these at least. Another issue is that CVC4 tries to download dependencies from the internet during build, which the opam sandbox doesn't allow. So some patching of makefiles / configure files will be required. I didn't look into Vampire as yet - maybe it is easier.
To come to the point: I would say your best bet to get a reliable working environment with CoqHammer and all supported ATPs - that is one which doesn't break on every update of Coq, your OS, ... - is to work with the Coq Platform team to get the remaining supported ATPs into opam and Coq Platform. Adding at least one of them for the next Coq Platform release (due in a few weeks) might be feasible. I would suggest to discuss further steps in the Coq Platform channel in the Coq Zulip.
Best regards,
Michael
https://github.com/coq/platform
https://github.com/coq/platform/releases/tag/2022.01.0
https://coq.zulipchat.com/#narrow/stream/250632-Coq-Platform.20devs.20.26.20users
- [Coq-Club] Question about ATPs in CoqHammer, Richard Dapoigny, 02/11/2022
- Re: [Coq-Club] Question about ATPs in CoqHammer, Michael Soegtrop, 02/12/2022
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.