coq-club AT inria.fr
Subject: The Coq mailing list
List archive
Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform
Chronological Thread
- From: Pierre Roux <Pierre.Roux AT onera.fr>
- To: coq-club AT inria.fr
- Cc: Iaroslav Baranov <kciray8 AT gmail.com>
- Subject: Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform
- Date: Mon, 22 Jul 2024 08:08:51 +0200
- Authentication-results: mail2-smtp-roc.national.inria.fr; spf=None smtp.pra=Pierre.Roux AT onera.fr; spf=Pass smtp.mailfrom=Pierre.Roux AT onera.fr; spf=Pass smtp.helo=postmaster AT onera.onera.fr
- Ironport-data: A9a23:9MoCIatCFOxf+AuS3aAegpLp8ufnVI5aMUV32f8akzHdYApBsoF/q tZmKT3TOv2MMWLxetpwbIy1pBsDscPcxoc1Gwpp/y43RCoQgMeUXt7xwmXYb3rDdJWbJK5Ex 5xDMYeYdJhcolv0/ErF3m3J9CEkvU2wbuOgTrSCYEidfCc8IA85kxVvhuUltYBhhNm9Emult Mj7yyHlEAbNNwVcbCRMuspvlDs15K6u4GxC5ARnDRx2lAa2e0c9XMp3yZ6ZdCOQrrl8RoaSW +vFxbelyWLVlz9F5gSNz94X2mVTKlLjFVDmZkh+A8BOsTAezsAG6ZvXAdJHAathZ5plqPgqo DlFncTYpQ7EpcQgksxFO/VTO3kW0aGrZNYriJVw2CCe5xSuTpfi/xlhJEMLGJdbwehYOEdp+ OYZBxZQNRWfl/3jldpXSsE07igiBM7tMZkW/HZmwCvQS/g8KXzBa/yWuZkChGt22J0IQZ4yZ OJBAdZrRCzBbgdVNxEtD48utOCui2P2NTNCwL6QjfNovTSLlVUhjdABNvLEIYS4G/90s3y1m XDd4l7cAk8gMPWmnG/tHnWE3bKWzHqqBer+DoaQ/flzxVaX22Y7EwwTTVL9oP+ji0f4Vcg3F qAP0i0ooLI7skutQ8P0GROiyJKZgvICc9htNvd50w+i84zz7hyYKU5ZFTtdeMNz4afaWgcW/ lOOmtroAxlmv7uUVW+R+9+oQdWaY3Z9wYgqPnNscOcV3+QPtr3fmTrhdL5e/EOdidv4Azi2x DaHtiF4ia97YS83O0eTowivb9GE/8ahousJCuP/BD7NAuRRP9fNWmBQwQKHhcus1a7AJrV7g FAKmtKF8McFBoyXmSqGTY0lRe7zvqrfbmGB0QMzRvHNEghBHVb5Lei8BxkifS9U3josIFcFn WeN5F4Kuve/wlPwNvYoC25ONyja5fO9TIW8B628gitmZZ58bgbPuWlpa0CR1G2llkEwkKY5M JPTfYmhEWsWBL8vwSb+S+pVy7Igxi0kzmPeXtjywg6gyqKXeH+cTboeWGZinchihJ5oVD79q o4FX+PTkkU3eLOlOEH/r9VMRW3m2FBnWfgaXeQMLLXSSuencUl9Y8LsLUQJItc/wvQKx7uSp xlQmCZwkTLCuJEOEi3SAlgLVV8ldcoXQasTbHF8b2W7kWMue5iu56o5fp46N+tvvu96wPI+C 7FPd8ycC74dAn7K6hYMX6nb9YZCTRWMgR7RHiyHZDNkQYVsaTaU8fDZfyzu1hI0MAyJieUEr YedizzrGag4e1w6DeL9Su6e8FeqjH1MxMNwRxTpJ/dQSmXN8a9rCTL7i8EmEvpRLB7C5yC70 jyOCkwyvtj9oI4S8fjIi5ubroyvLfBMI0pCE0Tf7pe0LSP//Ff/8bRfUe2NQy/RZFn09Iqme +9R6fP2a98Do3pnrKt+FOxN4Z8lxt6yuYJf8BtoLE/LY3uvFLlkBHuMhutLl69Vw45mqRmEY V2O9vZaKIe2FpvcSnBJHzUcb8OHyf0wsRvR565sIEzFuQlGzIDeWkBWZxSxmChRKYVuC7wcw MAjhdU37jKugR97I/eEiSFpr163FEIiaJl+lJ8mA97MsDEJm3Viep3XDxHk7K6fM+tsNlYYG R7Kpa7gqYkF+G/8XSsSL1bv09BZp6wygzFR7VpbJ122itvP3fA2+xtK8AUIdAdezzQZ8uciJ 1pbFU1RIJef3jZ3hfpsW3KnNBFBCSa4pG3w6Qotv0/IQ3a4UlfiKDUGBt+M20QC4kRgfjR/1 5OJ+lbPCDrFUpn44XovZBRDtffmc+1UyiTDv8KWR+K+AJgwZGvesJ+EPGYnhUPuPpIsuRfhu +JvwedXbJ/7Pw42p4kQKdGT9ZYUeSC+CF1ye9NT14JXIjiEYxC34yaEFG6pcMAUJ/Dqz16xO /YzGu1xDSaBxAS8hRFFI5UTIo1Evu8jv/sDXbLJGVQokZWiqhhRjZaB0RSm2UEKRY11nNcfO 7HhUWuIMlatiEt+n07Pq8h5OVSEX+QUWT2k3M6J3bUIM7khrNBTdVoD1+ronneNbypi0RGmn CLCQK700eZn95VdpNbyGKB9FjSPdNb4VcWT0QWJq98VR8j+AcTPkAI0q1fcIAVdO4UKael3j bigtN3W3lvPmaQfCUT1usCmOfFSxMOQWOF3DJrGHENCl3HfZP62sgoxxW+oDLdozvVf35CDb CmlYpKScdU1ZY9s9EdNYXIDLydHWrXFVYa+lyaTtP/WNwM81zbAJ9aZ9XPES2FXWysLGp/mA D/PpPecyYFEnbtIGSM7KalqM71gLH/nfJkWRdn7mD2bL2uv23epmL/pkzg+4jDqVFiANuvH4 qz+exuvTyTq5Zn0z+xYvbIr71dTRDx4jPIrd00Qx89uhnroRCQaJOAaKtMdBosSjiX204ria SrQaHc5Tx/wRilAbQ629eGLst1z3QDSEoyRyv0VE0Koh+OeA4WNGrIn8SFt+X4wdCGLICSPN 4QF4nOpVvSu6sgBeArRzqXTbSRbKjfywXQF40m7ndaa79M2H+ARzHI4dOZSfXWvLiwO/Xkn4 UAyQ21eSQe1UyYd1Cqml2F9QHkkgd8k89nkgepjDjoSV0V3AdCsEMHCBtw=
- Ironport-hdrordr: A9a23:cgb3qKN5s/yDk8BcTsejsMiBIKoaSvp037Dk7SFMoHtuA7Wlfq GV7ZImPHDP5Ar5NEtOpTnEAtjifZq+z/NICOsqTNOftWDd0QPCRr2Kr7GSoQEIcBefygcy78 ldmuRFebjN5QgTt7ec3DWF
- Ironport-phdr: A9a23:rlSKbhMBENUC5Ubqtk8l6napBxdPi9zP1u491JMrhvp0f7i5+Ny6Z QqDvq0r0QGCBN2Ao7Ic0qyK6fGmATRBqb+681k8M7V0FCU5wf0MmAIhBMPXQWbaF9XNKxIAI cJZSVV+9Gu6O0UGUOz3ZlnVv2HgpWVKQka3OgV6PPn6FZDPhMqrye+y54fTYwJVjzahfL9+N hq7oAvNusUMgYZvK6k9xgbVrnZGZu9awX9kKU+Jkxvz+Mu9+IRv/zhMt/4k6sVNTbj0c6MkQ LNXCzgrL3o76Mr3uxfdUACB/GEcUmIYkhpJBwjK8hT3VYrvvyX5q+RwxjCUMdX5Qr4oVzui6 bxrSALzhyccKzE56mDXhddug69dvRmsugZww4/QYIGSKfp+YqbQds4USGZdQspcUTFKD4WhZ IUNEuUBJ/5VoIbzqVUOsxWzGxSiC+HhyjBGhXH30rE13es6HAHa3wEgHc4CvGjOodj3MqoZT OC7zLPPzTXGd/5Ywzb955bSchA7v/6HQK5+cc3MyUggCgjIiU+eqY37MDOPzOQCrXKX4fZnV eKyhG8qsAZxoj6xycc2kIbFnIwVykrd+Ch/3Y06KsG2RlRhbt64DJtfqTuaN41uT84iX21lv Ds2x70EtJO/YiUHy4oryh/bZvGbfIWF4hPuWPiNLTpmhHxodqyyihis/UW91uHyWc253VVUo idKjtXBsG0G2RLU6siCUPR9/0Gh1C6A1wDS9uFEIV00mrHBJ5E9xb4wk4IfsVjDHiDon0X3j a6WdkAh+ue28eTnZ6/pppmaN4NujAHxLLgultS+AOQlNggOXnCb9vi81LL54U31WqlFjvozk qTfrZvUJtwbq7akDwJa3Ysv8QizAyup3dgCnHQKLEhJdR2fg4T0NVzDL+r0Aemij1iyijtn2 vTLMqH7DpjMKHXIjansfbJg605H1Ao808pf6Y9VCrAAPv3+QlP9udrFBREjKQO02fzoCNBl2 4MeR22PBqiZPbvVsV+O+O0vOfODaJUSuDb7Nfcl/eThgWU3mV8HZaWp3J0XZ26kHvl+PkmUb nXhjs0fHWsWsQcyVu3nhV2YXTNcf3qyWrgz5jA/CIKoF4fDQYWtjaSb0ie6AJJWfHpGBU6WH Xn0cIWERvgNZTmVIs9njDMET6KuR5Uv1RG0rAP6zaFoIfLO+iIErZLjyMR15+rLmB0v7TB0F diS03mRT2FomWMFXyM53KdmoUBk1liD1bV4jOdDGNxI5/JJVx86OoTGw+x7DdDyQAPBcc2TR FaoWNX1SQ02G9k22poFZ1t3M9SklBHKmSSwUJEPkLnePJ056LjRl0L2OtY1n07H2bM7gh8cR dZfHWqgi7R2sQbJUd2a236FnrqnIPxPlBXG832OmDLmVCBwVQdxVf+ARnUDfg7Mqt+/4EreT rioALBhMw1byMfEJLEZIsbxgwBgQ/HucM/bf3r3g325UC6Jy6mWYczQfHgN9CLbBVIN1Q4Jr j6dLQZrPi66uCrFCSB2U1fmYkfi6+57/Uu6Q1UuwkewaFBx/72z9wQcw/KGGLsIxrxRgC46s H1vGUqlmdLbD93Vvw16YKBVes8w+n9A02/Dvkp6OJG6JuZsnDbyaixRuEXjn1VyA4REy40xq W8yiRB1IuSe2U9AcDWR2dbxPKfWIy/85kLnbamewVzY3NuMn8VHoP0lt1Xuuh2oHUs+4j1m1 ddSyX6V+pTNCkIbT5vwVk898xUyqavdZ2Ex4Ibd1HskNqfR0HeK49MkHvEojCynYsd3N6WJD ga0HddbT8miJeo2mkS4OwoeNbMa/6o1MsW6Mvqejff3YKA6xG7g0zkBvNMYsArE7Sd3R+/W0 oxQxviZ2lHCTDLglBK7tcuxn4lYZDYUF275yC7+BYcXaLchGORDQWqoPcCzwc1zwpD3XHsNv maiCkkc1YmTfgeCR1v70BdZk0oN6y/C+2Pw33lvnjclo7DKlhTPzv74eVw9PXNbbG5kgE3lZ 4auxYN/PgDgf00ikx2r4lz/zq5QqfFkLmXddkxPejD/M2BoVqbYWqOqW8dU89totCxWVL75e lWGUvvnpBBc1Sr/HmxYzTR9djewu5y/kQYowG6aKX9yqjLed6QSjV/n5dHGX/MX5D0bVAF/j zTNDx6yJZGl8M6VmJHKru2lHzv9CtsJKXWtk97G6GOy/iVyDAe6nuyvl9GCc0ByyiL929RwF G3JoBv6foj3xvG/OONjcFNvAQy04M57F4di14oo0chMhT5A3snToydBzTSWU50Tw6/1YXsTS CRextfU5FKgw0h/NjeTwIm/UHyBw8xnbt38Y2UM2yt74doZbcXcpLFCgyZxpUK16AzLZv0o1 A8cxOE05TgghPwZkA0rwz+URL4IVxo9X2Skh1GT4tayob8CLl6ufKKq2QxEms2xJLaErxtVH njjMMRHf2c4/oB0N1TC12f244fvdYzLbN4dgRaTlg/Jk+lfLJ9i3upPnydsPnjx+GE00+Nux wI7xom05cLUTgcltLL8GBNTMSf5It8e6i24x7gLhd6YhsiuBskzQ2lXGsGwEbT2TXRO/f21M ACDCjR6rXGWA7OZExX6ig8urmqTQcn3azfNfCVflIskGVGcPBAN2VtIGm9jxNhgR1jsmITgd kx9+zwctET1oQFRy/5tPhj7FGzYoWLKIn89Gp2Pd1xM4wpY+kbJNMWf6qR4GCQQ/5uqqBGBJ z6AfwoOFXsORkGPG1HkOP+p+MXE9O+bQOG5Kp6sKf3LoOhaHZ9k3LqX25B9t3aJP8SLZDx5C uEjn1BEVjZ/EtjYnDMGT2oWkTjMZoiVvkX09ipyp8G5uPPlPWCnrZOIEKdXOM5z9gqehqGOL efWgyB0Mz8e2IlEyXLTybcZ1UIfkGk3K2XrS+xc83CQCv6Yk7QybVZTcy5pMcpU868wlhJAP 8LWkJK917J1iOI0F0YQVVHlnZLhbsgLLmehcVLfUR/XaPLcfWGNnZyxPfDZK/UYluhfuhyut CzOFkbiOm7GjDz1T1W1NuoKiiiHPRtYsYX7cxB3CGGlQsi1D3/zeNJxkzAyxqU5w33QMmtJe wB9fllXo/uq6j5IqvJ5FnZIqHR/Z7rh+W7R/6zDJ5AavOE+SDxzjP5f6W8mxqF96ydJXvUzn y3ftNcorUvswYztgnJ3FRFJrDhMnoeCu05vbL7Y+pd3UnHB5BsR7G+UBkdCt55/B9booawV1 snXmfe5NmJZ69yNt5h5ZYCcOIedPXEmKxasBDPEEF5PU2uwLW+Gz01FzKPLqiHT9MBm7Max3 sZGD7ZfUBZd/hwyDUJoBtVELo0lB1vMdJacisMS7DywtkuJLC27lpfBW+ibR/LpJSyQy7deN UJg/A==
- Ironport-sdr: 669df774_mDYkdaNIhL6OR6sGsX1RvdGeQvA1Sti+bw51bCdeBzxvlCA lA9VV138CjM4akcvOMVtiZBsvO7igbjY1TbOVhg==
About plugins, we have to be very careful that we absolutely don't want
to invite users to write plugins if they don't need it. Most use cases
of plugins are nowadays covered by metalanguages such as Ltac2 or coq-elpi
that should offer a much better experience in terms of maintenance
(OCaml plugins depend on Coq API that is unstable and breaks at each new
version). So considering the limited use cases, maybe we just don't need
additional teaching material here.
Le 2024-07-22 07:48, Iaroslav Baranov a écrit :
Hi Thomas!
Thank you very much for your effort to make coq more easy to learn! The
tutorial on Search and its tricks / advanced features is especially useful
for many coq users.
Do you have plans on creating any similar tutorials on coq plugin writing
in OCaml? I've recently decided to learn it, but found only 4
non-interactive demo projects. Or maybe you can recommend some if they do
exist somewhere
Best regards
On Thu, Jul 18, 2024, 4:47 PM thomas lamiaux <thomas.lamiaux AT inria.fr>
wrote:
Dear Coq users and developers,
We would like to shed some light on our new project "Coq Platform Doc".
Our goal is to provide an online compilation of short, practical and
interactive
tutorials and how-to guides about Coq and the Coq Platform. We wish this
content
to be part of the upcoming Rocq website. A detailed description of the
project can
be found in our Coq Enhancement Proposal (CEP) here:
https://github.com/coq/ceps/pull/91
The first few tutorials are available as well as a (very preliminary)
online
interface here:
https://www.theozimmermann.net/platform-docs/
(note that this is a temporary URL that will cease to be available
once the tutorials are migrated to the official Coq organization)
At this moment, it contains:
- a Search tutorial
- a Basic library file and module management tutorial
- 3 tutorials about the Equation plugin
More will follow, especially with your help!
There is a dedicated Zulip channel to discuss and participate:
https://coq.zulipchat.com/#narrow/stream/437203-Coq-Platform-docs
The preliminary git repository is https://github.com/Zimmi48/platform-docs
Any contribution would be greatly appreciated and we welcome in particular:
- help to improve or write tutorials or how-to guides
- comments or feedback on the project or existing tutorials or your needs
- new tutorials about your favorite feature/plugin
- help to turn folklore or secret powers into common knowledge
- propositions to enhance interactive and non-interactive interfaces
- reviews of our CEP
Do not hesitate to contact us, if you are interested in this project!
Formally yours,
--
Thomas Lamiaux (@thomas-lamiaux),
Pierre Rousselin (@Villetaneuse),
Théo Zimmermann (@Zimmi48)
- [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform, thomas lamiaux, 07/18/2024
- Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform, mukesh tiwari, 07/21/2024
- Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform, Iaroslav Baranov, 07/22/2024
- Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform, Pierre Roux, 07/22/2024
- Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform, John Beattie, 07/22/2024
- Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform, thomas lamiaux, 07/22/2024
- Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform, John Beattie, 07/22/2024
- Re: [Coq-Club] Coq Platform Docs: a documentation project for Coq and its Platform, Pierre Roux, 07/22/2024
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.