CGAL users discussion list

[Matthieu Chavent <>]

Sorry, I used not exactly the same file for the skin surface mesher: I 
join the good one with this mail. In fact, for cheng and chew program I 
have to pass the square of the weight (in the gramicidinA.tet file with 
the previous mail) and not in the skin surface mesher in CGAL. But, the 
questions stay the same...

Thank you in advance!!

    Matthieu Chavent 

Matthieu Chavent a écrit :
> Good evening,
>
> I use the skin surface mesher and I compare it with a Cheng and Chew 
> program that normally creates the same skin surface.. But When I use 
> the same data set the two surfaces are not exactly the same. Could I 
> have and explanation, please? And the two surface represent clearly 
> the skin surface? In particular, the hole in the center of the 
> molecule exists or not?
>
> Thank you in advance!!
>
> Regards,
>
>      Matthieu Chavent
>
> PS: I joined the file.
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------


--


---------------------------

Matthieu Chavent
LORIA
PhD student

tel: ++33(0)3-54-95-86-05

---------------------------

  -2.330  -0.205   1.496  1.55
  -3.501   0.435   2.070  1.70
  -3.595   0.079   3.555  1.70
  -3.911  -1.055   3.906  1.52
  -4.752   0.042   1.281  1.70
  -5.974   0.826   1.764  1.70
  -4.535   0.232  -0.221  1.70
  -3.315   1.072   4.387  1.55
  -3.364   0.879   5.826  1.70
  -2.503   1.917   6.549  1.70
  -3.009   2.947   6.992  1.52
  -1.218   1.610   6.645  1.55
  -0.282   2.504   7.305  1.70
   1.118   2.286   6.729  1.70
   1.488   1.161   6.395  1.52
  -0.333   2.271   8.817  1.70
   1.860   3.379   6.631  1.55
   3.212   3.322   6.101  1.70
   3.344   4.316   4.945  1.70
   3.076   5.504   5.109  1.52
   4.235   3.539   7.217  1.70
   5.653   3.290   6.701  1.70
   6.367   4.609   6.398  1.70
   6.446   2.419   7.676  1.70
   3.758   3.791   3.801  1.55
   3.929   4.617   2.617  1.70
   2.939   4.169   1.540  1.70
   2.972   3.022   1.100  1.52
   5.381   4.534   2.143  1.70
   2.080   5.099   1.149  1.55
   1.082   4.815   0.132  1.70
  -0.248   5.456   0.535  1.70
  -0.349   6.677   0.629  1.52
   1.580   5.284  -1.237  1.70
   2.863   4.551  -1.635  1.70
   0.496   5.113  -2.303  1.70
  -1.235   4.601   0.764  1.55
  -2.554   5.068   1.156  1.70
  -2.807   4.698   2.618  1.70
  -2.463   3.600   3.053  1.52
  -3.612   4.505   0.205  1.70
  -4.962   5.192   0.419  1.70
  -3.159   4.625  -1.252  1.70
  -3.408   5.635   3.337  1.55
  -3.713   5.421   4.742  1.70
  -3.197   6.608   5.557  1.70
  -3.535   7.756   5.271  1.52
  -5.212   5.179   4.922  1.70
  -5.618   3.813   4.366  1.70
  -5.618   5.317   6.390  1.70
  -2.386   6.292   6.556  1.55
  -1.820   7.318   7.415  1.70
  -0.305   7.108   7.467  1.70
   0.164   5.987   7.660  1.52
  -2.475   7.298   8.797  1.70
  -1.741   8.137   9.845  1.70
  -1.921   9.432  10.140  1.70
  -0.709   7.727  10.733  1.70
  -1.073   9.845  11.147  1.55
  -0.304   8.748  11.518  1.70
  -0.119   6.453  10.860  1.70
   0.697   8.654  12.492  1.70
   0.882   6.358  11.833  1.70
   1.299   7.409  12.641  1.70
   0.419   8.204   7.292  1.55
   1.871   8.154   7.318  1.70
   2.428   9.145   6.292  1.70
   2.400  10.354   6.513  1.52
   2.390   8.384   8.738  1.70
   3.913   8.530   8.734  1.70
   4.417   9.056  10.080  1.70
   4.589   7.215   8.343  1.70
   2.921   8.593   5.193  1.55
   3.484   9.412   4.133  1.70
   2.866   8.961   2.807  1.70
   2.395   7.830   2.692  1.52
   5.013   9.339   4.136  1.70
   5.658   9.862   5.421  1.70
   5.406  11.012   6.061  1.70
   6.662   9.244   6.214  1.70
   6.186  11.143   7.192  1.55
   6.985  10.008   7.279  1.70
   7.302   8.004   6.006  1.70
   7.941   9.666   8.243  1.70
   8.258   7.662   6.969  1.70
   8.590   8.449   8.066  1.70
   2.890   9.867   1.842  1.55
   2.338   9.576   0.529  1.70
   1.067  10.402   0.320  1.70
   1.135  11.556  -0.100  1.52
   3.395   9.791  -0.556  1.70
   4.677   9.029  -0.214  1.70
   4.492   7.525  -0.421  1.70
   5.868   9.575  -1.005  1.70
  -0.062   9.778   0.623  1.55
  -1.346  10.442   0.474  1.70
  -2.250   9.984   1.621  1.70
  -2.045   8.913   2.189  1.52
  -1.947  10.169  -0.906  1.70
  -1.155  10.783  -2.061  1.70
  -1.276  12.011  -2.584  1.70
  -0.120  10.186  -2.832  1.70
  -0.387  12.210  -3.621  1.55
   0.346  11.038  -3.770  1.70
   0.421   8.889  -2.714  1.70
   1.365  10.737  -4.682  1.70
   1.441   8.589  -3.625  1.70
   1.920   9.466  -4.591  1.70
  -3.233  10.819   1.926  1.55
  -4.168  10.515   2.996  1.70
  -3.957  11.496   4.150  1.70
  -4.386  12.646   4.077  1.52
  -5.603  10.493   2.462  1.70
  -5.836   9.251   1.600  1.70
  -6.394   8.100   2.440  1.70
  -6.731   9.575   0.402  1.70
  -3.294  11.006   5.187  1.55
  -3.020  11.827   6.354  1.70
  -1.606  11.501   6.840  1.70
  -1.000  10.529   6.391  1.52
  -4.086  11.619   7.433  1.70
  -5.514  11.885   6.956  1.70
  -6.165  13.056   6.907  1.70
  -6.463  10.949   6.459  1.70
  -7.445  12.904   6.417  1.55
  -7.624  11.555   6.134  1.70
  -6.312   9.557   6.289  1.70
  -8.748  10.897   5.619  1.70
  -7.435   8.900   5.774  1.70
  -8.631   9.524   5.439  1.70
   0.210  12.145   8.302  1.70
  -1.122  12.332   7.751  1.55
   1.207  13.019   7.538  1.70
   1.257  12.684   6.153  1.52
   2.276   0.179   1.481  1.55
   3.451  -0.461   2.047  1.70
   3.555  -0.104   3.532  1.70
   3.873   1.031   3.880  1.52
   4.697  -0.068   1.250  1.70
   5.922  -0.852   1.725  1.70
   4.470  -0.260  -0.250  1.70
   3.281  -1.096   4.366  1.55
   3.339  -0.902   5.805  1.70
   2.482  -1.940   6.534  1.70
   2.991  -2.970   6.974  1.52
   1.198  -1.633   6.638  1.55
   0.267  -2.527   7.305  1.70
  -1.138  -2.309   6.738  1.70
  -1.509  -1.185   6.406  1.52
   0.327  -2.293   8.816  1.70
  -1.880  -3.402   6.645  1.55
  -3.235  -3.345   6.124  1.70
  -3.375  -4.340   4.970  1.70
  -3.106  -5.528   5.133  1.52
  -4.251  -3.562   7.247  1.70
  -5.672  -3.313   6.740  1.70
  -6.388  -4.632   6.443  1.70
  -6.459  -2.441   7.720  1.70
  -3.796  -3.816   3.828  1.55
  -3.975  -4.642   2.646  1.70
  -2.992  -4.195   1.562  1.70
  -3.028  -3.048   1.121  1.52
  -5.431  -4.560   2.181  1.70
  -2.136  -5.126   1.166  1.55
  -1.144  -4.842   0.142  1.70
   0.188  -5.482   0.537  1.70
   0.290  -6.704   0.631  1.52
  -1.651  -5.312  -1.223  1.70
  -2.937  -4.579  -1.613  1.70
  -0.574  -5.141  -2.296  1.70
   1.176  -4.627   0.759  1.55
   2.498  -5.094   1.143  1.70
   2.761  -4.723   2.603  1.70
   2.419  -3.626   3.039  1.52
   3.550  -4.532   0.184  1.70
   4.901  -5.219   0.390  1.70
   3.088  -4.653  -1.269  1.70
   3.367  -5.660   3.318  1.55
   3.680  -5.446   4.721  1.70
   3.170  -6.632   5.540  1.70
   3.506  -7.780   5.253  1.52
   5.181  -5.203   4.891  1.70
   5.583  -3.837   4.332  1.70
   5.596  -5.340   6.357  1.70
   2.365  -6.315   6.544  1.55
   1.805  -7.341   7.408  1.70
   0.290  -7.131   7.470  1.70
  -0.177  -6.010   7.665  1.52
   2.469  -7.320   8.785  1.70
   1.742  -8.158   9.839  1.70
   1.924  -9.452  10.133  1.70
   0.716  -7.748  10.733  1.70
   1.083  -9.865  11.146  1.55
   0.316  -8.768  11.521  1.70
   0.127  -6.473  10.863  1.70
  -0.679  -8.673  12.502  1.70
  -0.868  -6.378  11.843  1.70
  -1.280  -7.428  12.654  1.70
  -0.434  -8.227   7.300  1.55
  -1.886  -8.177   7.335  1.70
  -2.450  -9.168   6.314  1.70
  -2.421 -10.377   6.535  1.52
  -2.396  -8.406   8.759  1.70
  -3.919  -8.552   8.765  1.70
  -4.414  -9.077  10.115  1.70
  -4.597  -7.237   8.378  1.70
  -2.950  -8.617   5.218  1.55
  -3.520  -9.437   4.162  1.70
  -2.911  -8.986   2.832  1.70
  -2.441  -7.856   2.713  1.52
  -5.049  -9.363   4.175  1.70
  -5.685  -9.886   5.464  1.70
  -5.430 -11.035   6.103  1.70
  -6.685  -9.267   6.263  1.70
  -6.203 -11.165   7.239  1.55
  -7.000 -10.031   7.331  1.70
  -7.326  -8.027   6.059  1.70
  -7.950  -9.688   8.301  1.70
  -8.276  -7.685   7.028  1.70
  -8.600  -8.471   8.127  1.70
  -2.941  -9.893   1.867  1.55
  -2.398  -9.603   0.550  1.70
  -1.128 -10.429   0.334  1.70
  -1.199 -11.583  -0.085  1.52
  -3.462  -9.819  -0.527  1.70
  -4.741  -9.056  -0.177  1.70
  -4.559  -7.552  -0.386  1.70
  -5.937  -9.603  -0.960  1.70
   0.002  -9.805   0.629  1.55
   1.286 -10.468   0.472  1.70
   2.197 -10.010   1.613  1.70
   1.996  -8.939   2.181  1.52
   1.878 -10.197  -0.912  1.70
   1.078 -10.811  -2.062  1.70
   1.196 -12.040  -2.585  1.70
   0.038 -10.215  -2.826  1.70
   0.300 -12.239  -3.616  1.55
  -0.434 -11.068  -3.761  1.70
  -0.502  -8.918  -2.705  1.70
  -1.459 -10.767  -4.666  1.70
  -1.528  -8.618  -3.610  1.70
  -2.013  -9.496  -4.572  1.70
   3.182 -10.845   1.912  1.55
   4.124 -10.540   2.975  1.70
   3.921 -11.521   4.131  1.70
   4.350 -12.671   4.056  1.52
   5.555 -10.519   2.432  1.70
   5.783  -9.277   1.568  1.70
   6.347  -8.125   2.403  1.70
   6.670  -9.602   0.364  1.70
   3.265 -11.030   5.172  1.55
   2.998 -11.850   6.342  1.70
   1.587 -11.523   6.837  1.70
   0.979 -10.552   6.391  1.52
   4.071 -11.642   7.414  1.70
   5.496 -11.908   6.927  1.70
   6.146 -13.079   6.875  1.70
   6.441 -10.972   6.424  1.70
   7.424 -12.927   6.376  1.55
   7.601 -11.578   6.091  1.70
   6.290  -9.580   6.254  1.70
   8.721 -10.921   5.568  1.70
   7.409  -8.923   5.731  1.70
   8.603  -9.548   5.388  1.70
  -0.219 -12.167   8.311  1.70
   1.109 -12.354   7.751  1.55
  -1.221 -13.041   7.554  1.70
  -1.280 -12.708   6.169  1.52
  -1.409   0.501   0.859  1.70
  -1.445   1.720   0.692  1.52
   1.351  -0.528   0.850  1.70
   1.386  -1.747   0.684  1.52