Subject: CGAL users discussion list
List archive
- From: lien lee <>
- To:
- Subject: [cgal-discuss] The surface mesher works incorrectly
- Date: Wed, 7 Oct 2009 09:27:12 -0400
- Domainkey-signature: a=rsa-sha1; c=nofws; d=gmail.com; s=gamma; h=mime-version:in-reply-to:references:date:message-id:subject:from:to :content-type; b=GpoVge/hvTqUKdMJIc+MQDXFTfXP2/GUSybMfCer2MCg1nxbIxcFX6/ALM4rvBBowm Mkexbu9DRpKmg8S5G6TpXf6tvJKWfZhMB0K5diJG+jPYbgtzI0e2LHh+idQpgvpkqgGK rGtdXhD/EhEKHaRnixfRSe1C7nELi414MkvuM=
Hi,
I am a newbie of CGAL, and I tried CGAL 3.5 release these days. WinXP on 32bit machine; MSVC2008.
Before I installed CGAL 3.5 with the CGAL-3.5-Setup.exe, I installed:
boost 1.39.0,
cmake-2.6.4-win32-x86.exe,
LEDA-6.2-free-win32-msc9-std-multithread.exe,
I tried “mesh_an_implicit_function.cpp” again. From “mesh_a_3d_gray_image.cpp”, I copied the code needed to output the mesh to off file. The problem remains, as seen in attached “out_sphere.jpg”.
Actually, I tried with CGAL-3.4-Setup.exe today, and I got the same results. The meshes look ugly with many holes, which is quite different with that in the manual.
I queried the FAQ and achieve, and I can’t find similar threads. But, I learned that some ones DO have successful experience of using the surface mesher.
Best,
--Hongbin Zhu
I am a newbie of CGAL, and I tried CGAL 3.5 release these days. WinXP on 32bit machine; MSVC2008.
Before I installed CGAL 3.5 with the CGAL-3.5-Setup.exe, I installed:
boost 1.39.0,
cmake-2.6.4-win32-x86.exe,
LEDA-6.2-free-win32-msc9-std-multithread.exe,
qt-sdk-win-opensource-2009.04.exe,
libQGLViewer-installer.exe,
then I stated up the CGAL-3.5-Setup.exe with those precompiled GMP, MPFR and taucs libs included.
I made the VC projects with command “cmake-gui” following the installation guide. After all red entries being removed, the IDE targets were generated with variables of “WITH_examples”, “WITH_demo”, “WITH_GMP” checked (ON). Then, I open the generated “CGAL.sln” and compile it. Four libs were generated successfully except CGAL_Qt3 and CGAL_Qt4. I just leave the two CGAL_Qt libs aside, since I am just interested with the surface mesher example.
I then run the example with the “mesh_a_3d_gray_image.cpp” without any
modification made to the original code. The output “out.off” is at
attached. After removing the third empty line in the off file, the mesh
is visualized as attached “out_grayimage.jpg”. As can be seen, there
are a lot of holes on the mesh (I don't think they are caused by back face culling since there is no triangle at the holws if I show the mesh in the mode of wireframe).libQGLViewer-installer.exe,
then I stated up the CGAL-3.5-Setup.exe with those precompiled GMP, MPFR and taucs libs included.
I made the VC projects with command “cmake-gui” following the installation guide. After all red entries being removed, the IDE targets were generated with variables of “WITH_examples”, “WITH_demo”, “WITH_GMP” checked (ON). Then, I open the generated “CGAL.sln” and compile it. Four libs were generated successfully except CGAL_Qt3 and CGAL_Qt4. I just leave the two CGAL_Qt libs aside, since I am just interested with the surface mesher example.
I tried “mesh_an_implicit_function.cpp” again. From “mesh_a_3d_gray_image.cpp”, I copied the code needed to output the mesh to off file. The problem remains, as seen in attached “out_sphere.jpg”.
Actually, I tried with CGAL-3.4-Setup.exe today, and I got the same results. The meshes look ugly with many holes, which is quite different with that in the manual.
I queried the FAQ and achieve, and I can’t find similar threads. But, I learned that some ones DO have successful experience of using the surface mesher.
Best,
--Hongbin Zhu
Attachment:
out_grayimage.jpg
Description: JPEG image
Attachment:
out_sphere.jpg
Description: JPEG image
Attachment:
out.rar
Description: Binary data
- [cgal-discuss] The surface mesher works incorrectly, lien lee, 10/07/2009
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.