Subject: Discussion related to cado-nfs
List archive
Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS
Chronological Thread
- From: hermann@stamm-wilbrandt.de
- To: Paul Zimmermann <Paul.Zimmermann@inria.fr>
- Cc: cado-nfs@inria.fr
- Subject: Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS
- Date: Mon, 17 Jul 2023 21:12:09 +0200
- Authentication-results: mail2-smtp-roc.national.inria.fr; spf=None smtp.pra=hermann@stamm-wilbrandt.de; spf=None smtp.mailfrom=hermann@stamm-wilbrandt.de; spf=None smtp.helo=postmaster@nx114.node02.secure-mailgate.com
- Ironport-data: A9a23:pkFR0a4aLqlMUyGt7tLNSwxRtLPDchMFZxGqfqrLsTDasY5as4F+v jQfUWHVOPiIMzSkc90jOY6//BhS78KHzYA3TAFornpkZn8b8sCt6faxfh6hZXvKRiHgZBs6t JtGMoGowOQcFCK0SsKFa+C5xZVE/fjUAOC6UoYoAwgpLSd8UiAtlBl/rOAwh49skLCRDhiE0 T/Ii5S31GSNhXgsawr414rZ8Ek05Kur52tB1rADTakjUGH2xyF94K03fvnZw0vQGuF8AuO8T uDf+7C1lkuxE8AFV7tJOp6iGqE7aua60Tqm0hK6aID+6vR2nRHe545gXBYqhei7vB3S9zx54 I0lWZVd0m7FNIWU8AgWe0Ew/y2TocSqUVIISJSymZX78qHIT5fj68RBKURpAIEfwepuDjlp/ 8RfOgAWLQ/W0opawJrjIgVtrsIzdZC3eoUYtnw4l3fCAP07W52GRqzL4dBRwDp2jcdLdRrcT 5NIM3w2Mk6GM0IJYw5LYH49tL/Aan3XczBCrVuTo4Is/2HWyUlu0bznKtPTdsDMScg9ckOw/ zuZrzumXkFEXDCZ4TmA8UyquOjRpi3Qf6QrTbCotd9wrWTGkwT/DzVNDQDr/Kjg4qKkYPpNK kkR9zArpIAg9UmhVNC7XhuioXfCsAR0c9FZH+p/7g+W4rHF5h6QQGkCVD9ILtI83PLaXhQsx gbQw5XvAjBi6OfTUn+W662Z6Da7OCwaJHMPIyQDSGPp/uUPvqkCoTfKEetvF5W5l9KtPjvIh CK6t2sh0uB7YdEw6423+lXOgjSJr5fPTxIo6gi/Yo5Dxl4pDGJCT9H3gWU3/cqsP67EFwPQ7 SNsd9y2vbxfVMnleDmlGr1VdIxF8cppJxXwrDZS83QJ8ST0oiLle4dc7WkkYlxkOdsedHrsa U7XtgpN6dlYO37CgU5Lj2CZVZtCIUvIT4iNuhXogjxmPsMZmOivp3EGWKJo9zqx+HXAaIlmU XthTe6iDGwBFYNsxyesSuEW3NcDn35ulD6IH8qgkk33iNJygUJ5r59bbjNiichnscu5TPn9q Yc32zailUgCC7OWjtf/qt5Ldzjm0kTX9bit85cHK7/aSuaXMG0mBPbdxvsufoZl95m5Zc+Xl kxRrnRwkQKl7VWecFXiQi44M9vHA80gxU/XyARwZj5ELVB4Ot/0hEreHrNrFYQaGBtLlq8tE aFcIZTQXZyiiF3volwgUHU0l6Q6HDzDuO5EF3PNjOEXLscwFT/asMTpZBXu/yQoBy+6/5l26 b652w+RBdJJSw1+BYyEILii3nGgj0g7wehSZkrvJsUMWUPO9IMxFTf9oMVqKO4xKDLC5ACg6 SCoPTkiq9LgmbQFqOvyufjcrqOCMfdPIU5BLmyKsZe0LXb7+0Sg869hUcGJXyLRe03o8p77P uxq3/D3NdMarnZzrrhTLrdP5oA97uvJuLV14FlFHnLKTlLzEZJmACCM8vduv5135I1ymFWJS GPV3/cCIpSPGsfuMGBJFTofdu7ZiM0lwGjD38o6MGDRxXFR/oPedW5wIhPVqihWDIUtAbMf2 e175fInsV2uuCELbOSDoDtfrVmXD3o6VK4iiJEWLanrhicvyXBAeZbsMTD30r7ed+RzNlQWH RHMiJrgn7h8wm/wQ0g3H1XJ3stfgs0AgwAV7VkgI1/SpMHJqMVq1zJs8BM2bD9v8DN578xJN FJWanJFfZe1w28whexofXydJAVaNRjIpm3z0wQokUPafWmJV0vMDn8xFsiR9ntAqGtjbjlQ+ Z+F+kbcTATFQcDV9QkxUH5DtPbMY4FQ9ArDucb/BOWDPcAwTgTEi5+UR1gjikXYE+JroWOfv shs3uJ7SZOjBB4qu6dhVrWrj+UBei6LNElpYK9H/ppQOUr+ZTvr+zyFC37pS/N3P/aQrHOJU Z1/FPluCSa7+j2F9A0AJKg2JLRxov4lyfwCdp7vJk8Eq7GvlSVogr2B6hnBgHIXfPs2nfYfM o/xcxewIl6Uj1ZQmE7Pq5BKAXrnQN8mYAan4vu53t9UHL0+scZtU3oI7J2Kg1uvPjBKwTeor SLYRqqPz+Vd2YVmxITtNaNYBjSLE9D4VcXW0QXu7/FyQIvrNJrQhSwotXzmYhZkAp1IUNFKi b6ynsb980/FsJkLTlGDyoWgFrZI1+q2TuF4IsL6F1gEvCqgCevHwQoPxHC8ErNNyOhi38iAQ xCqTeeBbvsHco956FwMTAYGCDcbKaD8Tpm4lBOHt/7WVyQsi13WHu2o5VrCTD99dBZRH7bcF wWtmfKlxu4AnbR2HBVeWs1XWc5pEmTCB5kjWcb67wSDL2+ShViHhLvuuDwg5RzPCViGCMzK2 o3EdDevaCWNvLz08/8Bv7xQphE3CFNPsds0dG8Z+P90jGm0MjdXZ6BVe5ALEYpdnSHOxYn1L mOFJncrDSLmGy9Ia1Pg6dDkRR2SHfEKJsy/HDEy4keIcG2jMets2le6GvtIuB+auwcPzd1L7 fkY6iSpYl63xZ1kHbxV/fGwnP1qg/bTx3YH8Fzw1cf1Bn7yxFnMOGNJRGJwue7vSqkhV3kn4 UAuWWlBRQSkSEr7C89md2ITFBxxUPYDCdk3RX/n/Tsc0rl3CMVb1PT6PqTs07kJds0MKKJIS X6fq65hJYyJ8iR7hJbFcO7FTUO55Txn0yR6wGLeqdUuopyN
- Ironport-hdrordr: A9a23:QdpeTaEe3seyl/xlpLqFh5HXdLJyesId70hD6qkQc20lTiVXrb HMoB19726OtN9xYgBZpTnuAse9qB/nlKKdpLNhWItKPzOIhILLFvAF0WKK+VSJcEDDH6xmpM NdmsNFeb/N5DZB7foSrDPIdOrJCbO8gdWVbLDlvgtQpYYBUdAb0+/+YDzrb3GftWN9dOgE/P 313LsymxOQPU4aZNihCl0MX+3Mr8DG0L/hZRYHAHccmXazpALt0rLxDwOV+h8fVj1G3Ltn0W XIlBH4+7XLiZvW9jbsk1Xe5YhMlP/oyt5MDNGBzu4INzvrigGnIK5lU6eZ1QpF0N2H2RIRnN PRuBsFN8R35XvNciWSvQbi3Qnm3nID9H/uxViTjRLY0L/EbQN/McZKmZlUVhPY7kQpod057L hGxGWQs5Y/N2K/oMysj+K4Li1Xqg==
- Ironport-phdr: A9a23:meJF4RM9fdW4wOE2ThIl6naGBxdPi9zP1u491JMrhvp0f7i5+Ny6Z QqDv6sr0AWCBN6Ao9t/yMPu+5j6XmIB5ZvT+FsjS7drEyE/tMMNggY7C9SEA0CoZNTjbig9A dgQHAQ9pyLzPkdaAtvxaEPPqXOu8zESBg//NQ1oLejpB4Lelcu62/6z9pHJbAhEmjWxba58I Ri4sA7cqtQYjYx+J6gr1xDHuGFIe+NYxWNpIVKcgRPx7dqu8ZBg7ipdpesv+9ZPXqvmcas4S 6dYDCk9PGAu+MLrrxjDQhCR6XYaT24bjwBHAwnB7BH9Q5fxri73vfdz1SWGIcH7S60/VC+85 Kl3VhDnlCYHNyY48G7JjMxwkLlbqw+lqxBm3oLYfJ2ZOP94c6jAf90VWHBBU95eWCJPAo2yc ZUCAfcDMuZWoYbzpFQPogexCwmtH+7v1j1Fhn3q0aEmyektDwfL1xEgEdIUt3TUqc34NKcMX uCvyanH1zPDb/VN1Dfm9IjHaBUhofSVUbN+cMrRzVIgFxnfgVWWtIPlIymZ2fkTvGWd8uFvW v6hhXQ9pAFtvjig2N0sio/Ri48WxV3K+zl0zYY7KNO3VkJ2fcOpHZleuS2EOYZ7QMwvTm52t Ss6xLALp5G2cTQXxJkp2xPSZPOJf5SL7xztUOucJypzinxieLK6nRmy8E6gx/XnVsmoyllKq y9FnsDCt3AM0xzc8dKHReF7/ki8xTaDzR3c5f9cLUA1k6rbMZ8hzaQqmpodq0TPBjH2mELrg 6CMeEUk/e6o5Pr+brXnvp+QLZJ7hR/4P68zmcK/Gfw1PhUKUmSF4+iwybzu8VPjTLhJjPA6i LTVvI3VKMgDoqO0DRVZ34I/5xqlEjur0tYVkWMIIV5Zfh+MkpXkNEvTL/7kE/i/m0mskCtly fDBO73uGJTNLn7bnbf/erZy9lRTyAQ0zdBZ+Z1YE7ABIOrpVkDsqtPVCAIyPRauzOb9Etp90 5sTWWKRDa+dN6PfqVmI5+0yL+WRa4IZojD9K/846PHwkXM1h0URfbK30pQLdXC4BOppL1ycY XX2g9cBFWgKsRAiTOP0klGNTTlTZ3OqU6I94DE0Fp6mAJ/eSo2pnrCNxjq3E5xIamxcCV2BE 23ke5iZV/oDcC6SJ9Vukj0AVbivUY8h0hSuuRf6y7V5NOrU/zcXtZTl1NVu/O3TiQs99TlxD 8iE3WCNTmV0kXgSRzAs2qBwvFB9xk2e3qdmm/BYE8dc6OtTUggmLZ7c0/B6C9fqVw7fZtuJU kqpQs26ATEtSdI8294PY0d4G9WnkB/DxS+qDKUOmr2KBZw097nT32LrKMpnynbG0rMhj1g8T cdVO22mnLZz9xLPCI7Rj0WZi6GqeLwA0yHX6WiDynOCvEdWUA5rSqjFRnAeZk7Ordvj/E/CT rmuCa4mMgRb08KCJLFKOZXVigB+TerncObfZme8gWK5AxDAkouFcY6sSWQY2SjHDUEClSgS+ 2yHPE4wHHHyjXjZCWluGEjqakXq2fJioXa+C1A1ywuQZktty/y5901GzceAQu8ei+pX8Bwqr C95SRPkh4q+47uoogNgeP8ZetYh+BJd0mmfsQVhP5umJqQkh1gEcg0xsVm9nw5vBNBmls4n5 Ggv0BI0MbiRhVNMbTaR25bYIaHeL2y34xGrYbTf3F3Cltqbqe8U8PptjVLlsUmyE1Y6tXBu0 t1byXyZs5XHFg8bV5TZSVo+8h0/uLDeaDM04Y/Ik3FhYuGvqjGX/dUvCaM+zwq4OddSNKTRD AjpD8gTHNSjMsQsiwHwMlQCO+xfrPRyJM6tauGLnauiPeJvlS6ry29A5eiRy2qq8CxxAq7N1 pcBmbSD2xefEi37hxGnu9z2noZNYXcTGHC+wG7qHtwZYKo6ZosNBWq0Rq//jtxjm57gXWJZ/ 1+/FhsH3sGuYx+bc13620VZy00WpXWtnSbwwSZzlnklqa+W3SqGxOqHFlJPOmNRQWBki3/3P YGxipUFXUyidQEvmAfj6Uu7j6lXqaJjLnXCFF9SdnuTTSkqWa+xu7yeJs9Xvcp562MODr76M Q/cE+eh8H54m2v5EmBTxS42bWSvs5T9xVlhjX6FaWx0pzzfcN1xwhHW4JrdQ+RQ13wIXnod6 3GfC16iMt2u5djRmY3Et7X0V2+7U5RVdwHw0YqFsW6k5GlgGxS5k+z1ltCtQm1YmWfrksJnU ynFtkO2YoTx0q28N8p8YkBtARrj6s5wAIh4npd2iJxaih14zt2FuHEAl2n0K9BS36nzOWEMS TA8yNnQ+AH52UdnIxpl3qrfUXOQiotkbti+OCYN3z4lqtpNA+GS5aBFmi18phy5qxjQaL5zh GVVz/xm83Mcj+wT3WhlhiyAHrAfG1VZNi3whlyJ6d65tqBeeGeod/C5ykN/mdmrCLzKrBtbX T71fZIrHCk46csaUhqE0HDp74jifvHLcdsWs1iLkhPKleFTJI53mvdLzStrNGThvGE0nusyj Bhgx5a/7+3lYy1m+KO0BAIdNyWgPpJJvGiz1+AOwYDPhtz8e/cpUi8GV5bpU/+yRTcbtPC9c h2LDCV5sHCQX7zWAQ6Y7k5i6XPJCZGicX+Ndxx7hZ1vQgeQIEtHjUUaRjI/y9Q5GxqvzcrnW Fxl7zUUo0H5rhFWw+RkK1/zXy2MwWXgIidxU5WZIBdMu0tC6l3QOMqYxvlvFiRdu4KgqAaXI 2qXe0JEACtaPy7MT0CmNb6o697a9uGeDefrNPrCb4KFrulGXuuJz5aiumd/1xCLMMjHfnxrD vlhn1FGQWg8AcPS3TMGVy0QkSvJKc+dvha1vCNt/Ii597zwVQTj6JHqafMaOMhz+x2wnaaIN vKBzCd/JzFC05oQxHjOgLEB1V8WgitqenGjC7MF/SLKSavRnOdQAXt5I2trM9BU6qsnwgRXE cjL04qpkLh/gvNtURFeWFf8gMzsYMULJ260KF6BD0GOdfyHKTDN38DrcPa8RLlX34A2/1W7v TeWFVOmPyzWzmizEUnxa6cc02fCZUAN3eP1OgxgAmXiUt/8PxiyMdstyCYz3aVxnHTBc2gVL Tl7dUpJ6LyW9yJRxPtlSAkjpjJoK/eJnyGB4qzWMJET5LFrDz5xnuRcyG8mwr5QqT5FQPZvk S3esphirhv194vHgioiSxdIpjtR0ciTul5+PKzC6pRacXDUpUtRq2OXBxlS/Z1+B9byoa0Vz 9HOkK36NDoE+NXRt5h5ZYCcOIeMN3wvNgDsETjfAV4eTDKlAmrYglRUjPCY8nD9Rn0SsYTln Z9LVb5fXkY8EP8GTEhoToRqyHhfRS8tlLvek88M72C3qhXNAslX7MivvhO6B+W2cWrfi75Ia kNSh6j1JpkJO8j+0k1mZVBmkcLBHE+CBbhw
- Ironport-sdr: 64b5928e_qVscio83g0kYcr4cJG8ruvBOiVB3NRsnIT48bKEEfMdIN78 dVZ4yzOxZ8gggqXLebGrLAnCetIJ1PoYGX691Kw==
On 2023-07-16 07:30, Paul Zimmermann wrote:
What I wanted you to try is only run the characters command, after copying theHi Paul,
files computed on the Pi400.
PC was rebooted, so /tmp/cado... was gone.
I extracted the tar file and ran the characters command, completed without issues in 4 seconds, see below.
You can try yourself, I uploaded that (1.1GB) .tar.gz file:
https://stamm-wilbrandt.de/en/forum/cado.4x9eajs3.tar.gz
You need to create the two links I described in this posting
https://sympa.inria.fr/sympa/arc/cado-nfs/2023-07/msg00009.html
to be able to run.
Here is sha256sum just to be sure you will get unmodified file:
hermann@7600x:/tmp$ ssh web23.web138@stamm-wilbrandt.de
web23.web138@stamm-wilbrandt.de's password:
Last failed login: Mon Jul 17 21:09:33 CEST 2023 from ip-078-042-191-222.um17.pools.vodafone-ip.de on ssh:notty
There was 1 failed login attempt since the last successful login.
-chrootsh-4.2$ sha256sum httpdocs/en/forum/cado.4x9eajs3.tar.gz
81f0b1e2320b908d49b856fd7b55c9262cd1c67c20b696c3eb8be8c5a14e3fb0 httpdocs/en/forum/cado.4x9eajs3.tar.gz
-chrootsh-4.2$
The character command on same data succeeding on x86 Linux indicates, that the cado-nfs on arm CPU has a problem.
hermann@7600x:~$ cd /tmp
hermann@7600x:/tmp$ ls -l cado*
ls: cannot access 'cado*': No such file or directory
hermann@7600x:/tmp$ tar -zxf ~/cado.4x9eajs3.tar.gz
hermann@7600x:/tmp$ time /home/pi/cado-nfs/build/pi400-64/linalg/characters -poly /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.poly -purged /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.purged.gz -index /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.index.gz -heavyblock /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.dense.bin -out /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.kernel -ker /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.bwc/W -lpb0 25 -lpb1 26 -nchar 50 -t 1 > /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.characters.stdout.1 2> /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.characters.stderr.1
real 0m4.248s
user 0m4.535s
sys 0m0.052s
hermann@7600x:/tmp$ cat /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.characters.stderr.1
/home/pi/cado-nfs/build/pi400-64/linalg/characters.re9cc3be15 -poly /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.poly -purged /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.purged.gz -index /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.index.gz -heavyblock /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.dense.bin -out /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.kernel -ker /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.bwc/W -lpb0 25 -lpb1 26 -nchar 50 -t 1
# Warning: parameter nratchars is checked by this program but is undocumented.
Note: total 64 characters, including 14 trivial padding characters
Reading 1469231 (a,b) pairs from /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.purged.gz
Computing 64 characters for 1469231 (a,b) pairs
done building big character matrix at wct=4.0s
done building small character matrix at wct=4.2s
done reading heavy block of size 292975 x 32 at wct=4.2s
/tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.bwc/W: 64 vectors
Total: 64 kernel vectors
done reading 64 kernel vectors at wct=4.2s
Info: input kernel vectors reduced to dimension 61
done multiplying matrices at wct=4.2s
Computing left nullspace of 61 x 96 matrix
dim of ker = 23
Wrote 23 non-zero dependencies to /tmp/cado.4x9eajs3/c110.kernel
This includes 0 discarded zero dependencies, as well as 41 padding zeros
hermann@7600x:/tmp$
Regards,
Hermann.
- [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/12/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/12/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/12/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/13/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/13/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/15/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/16/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/16/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/17/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/17/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/20/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/21/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/24/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/24/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/24/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/28/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/16/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/16/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, hermann, 07/15/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/13/2023
- Re: [cado-nfs] cado-nfs.py factoring RSA-110 OK in 15:31min on AMD 7600X Ubuntu, fails on Debian based 64bit PiOS, Paul Zimmermann, 07/12/2023
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.